Court stops R950m Tshwane payment to PEU

‘The more I learn, the more concerned I get’ – Judge.

The City of Tshwane has been interdicted from making a payment of R950 million to its controversial prepaid smart metering service provider PEU Capital Partners.

The order stands until the pending review of the original contract has been finalised.

Before reading the order of the North Gauteng High Court, judge Bert Bam said the more he reads about the matter (in court documents), the more concerned he gets. He said he would refrain from saying anything more at this stage, but would deliver his full judgement with reasons within a week.

The ruling came after business-grouping AfriBusiness approached the court on an urgent basis to prevent the payment.

The payment was said to be for the PEU smart metering infrastructure, but AfriBusiness questioned the basis upon which the amount was arrived at.

The order further provides that neither millions of rands in a dedicated account, nor any other money would be paid to PEU for such infrastructure.

PEU would continue to provide the smart metering services and would be compensated for it until the finalisation of the review application. That prevents any disruption to the almost 13 000 Tshwane consumers who currently get their electricity supply via the PEU system.

This includes about 6 500 large power users and represents 55% of the city’s electricity revenue.

AfriBusiness has been ordered to apply to the deputy judge president within three weeks for a date for the review application.

The court order means that Accenture, which has been appointed by the city as service provider to replace PEU, would not be in a position to commence its contract before the review has been concluded. The city would therefore continue to do business with PEU for the time being.

During the proceedings advocate Cedric Puckrin (SC) for AfriBusiness accused the city of “cooking the books” in order to make provision for the R950 million payment in the city’s 2016/17 budget at the last minute, without properly informing council.

He said the payment is irregular and there is no guarantee that Accenture would buy the PEU infrastructure from the city, as the city and PEU argued. “It is a potential loss of R1 billion to the city’s tax payers,” he said.

AfriBusiness attorney Willie Spies welcomed the ruling and said the organisation has a strong case to have the original contract set aside, which would also apply to the subsequent onerous termination and interim services and transfer agreements.

He said the city had since October 2013 paid more than R2 billion to PEU for a service it could itself provide for R11 million per year. The court order prevents a further R1 billion from flowing to the company.




Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


There is just no end to the corruption that runs through our government.

Check the link and see if your able to see the name that stands out.

Thuli Zuma B.Compt (Hons) (UNISA), CA (SA)

Investment Banking Executive
Thuli has more than twelve years experience in investment banking and private equities having held various positions in a number of local entities, including the position of CEO at Worldwide African Investment Holdings.

When the same subject of PEU came up on Moneyweb a few months ago, Google showed there are two people (possibly more) with this name. One is related to Jacob, the other is not, but I could not establish which of the two is associated with PEU. Can anyone enlighten me?

We are very fortunate in SA that our courts are serving us well & filling the vacuum left by government to some degree. It is just disappointing to see that the Courts have to step in to stop blatantly incorrect and often biased decisions serving self interests. Also very disappointing to note that opposition parties flagged serious (and seemingly legitimate) concerns with the contract, which the City of Tshwane openly ignored and tried to defend.

End of comments.




Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: