You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to visit our Mobile web app instead?
 Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

Six myths about tax-free savings accounts

Setting the record straight.

JOHANNESBURG – As South African investors have started to weigh their tax-free savings account options since the launch on March 1, a number of questions (and misperceptions) have come to the fore.

In this article, Niki Giles, chief operating officer at Sygnia, highlights six incorrect assumptions about tax-free savings accounts.

  1. You don’t have access to your money until a future date

Giles says a lot of investors think they can’t access their money until some future date, but this is not the case. Investors have access to their money at any time (both the capital and the income).

However, once money is withdrawn from the account, any additional deposits will be subject to the annual capital contribution limit of R30 000 (and the lifetime capital contribution limit of R500 000), she says. Any contributions made, even if subsequently withdrawn from the savings account, will therefore forever be counted under the R500 000 lifetime limit.

For example: If Investor A deposits R30 000 into a tax-free savings account on March 1 2015, and another R30 000 on March 1 2016, and withdraws R15 000 on October 1 2016, the investor won’t be able to put the R15 000 back until March 1 2017 because they have already reached the R30 000 capital contribution limit for that tax year (March 1 2016 to February 28 2017).

She says some products on offer, such as fixed deposits, may have a maturity term, but in that case the money must be accessible within 32 days.

  1. Your capital is guaranteed

Giles says it is possible to lose money in a tax-free savings account, but it will depend on the underlying assets.

Tax-free savings accounts allow investments in a wide variety of asset classes (including equities, bonds, listed property and cash) with varying degrees of risk.

She says although National Treasury has specified that these investments shouldn’t be exposed to excessive market risk, it is not quite clear what exactly it considers to be excessive levels of market risk. Therefore different product providers have launched savings products underpinned by a variety of different investment options.

  1. Tax-free savings accounts work like retirement annuities (RAs)

Giles says there are quite a few differences between tax-free savings accounts and retirement annuities.

While investors generally use pre-tax money to invest in an RA, deposits into a tax-free savings account are made with after-tax money.

With both a tax-free savings account and an RA the growth in the account (capital gains, dividends and interest) will be tax-free, but with an RA there is also a tax deduction on the contribution. On the other hand, any withdrawals from a savings account are completely tax-free, while in case of an RA (or an annuity purchased after retirement) all withdrawals and income are taxable.

Money in a savings account is also accessible at any stage, while money invested in an RA cannot be accessed before age 55.

Another difference is that while an RA falls outside the estate of an investor upon his/her death, a big advantage, a tax-free savings account will form part of the estate.

Giles says although a tax-free savings account can’t be used as security for debt it can still be attached by creditors (unlike a retirement product that is protected).

  1. It is the most cost-effective way of saving

Giles says a tax-free savings account is not necessarily the most cost-effective way of saving.

While no investment options with performance fees are allowed within savings products, there is no restriction on the asset manager’s flat fee, she says. Some savings products charge enormous management fees.

The man in the street needs to be aware of what he is paying in fees to the asset manager, the product provider (possibly the linked investment service provider or LISP) and to the broker or financial advisor.  

  1. You can’t switch between product providers

Giles says investors won’t be able to transfer their tax-free savings account from one product provider to another during the current tax year, but this is a temporary arrangement.

National Treasury has indicated that the transfer of tax-free savings accounts will be allowed from March 1 next year.

  1. You can invest in shares through a tax-free savings account

Giles says currently legislation allows two kinds of platform providers to offer tax-free savings accounts – LISPs and stockbrokers. Most investors are very familiar with LISPs.

She says investors who do decide to access a tax-free savings account through a stockbroker will do so because they want access to exchange-traded funds (EFTs), which are allowed in the accounts.

However, direct share investments are not allowed in tax-free savings accounts. 

* This content was sponsored by Sygnia.

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.


To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

Great article Niki! Your comments on Tax Free investment are spot on. #1 – Even thou you have access to your investment during your lifetime, it is still the best practice just to leave this investment to maximise returns over time. As you’ve mentioned all deposits will accrue to annual and lifetime limits and therefore to replace withdrawals will count against investor.
I believe positioning this investment as “access if you need some cash, i.e. emergency money” to be the most misrepresented fallacy in the industry.

Strawman article. None of the above are or were myths. Just a sensationalist headline from a failing website. What a great pity.

“…While investors generally use pre-tax money to invest in an RA…” – Surely not. Or else I’ve been doing it wrong for years 🙂

Ermm ……If that is the case you may in fact have been doing it wrong. Your tax return that is. The money you use to invest in an RA may have been taxed at source but the full amount – with limitations – can be deducted from your taxable earnings thus reducing tax liability and therefore you get the tax originally deducted back. Hence pre-tax money. If you exceed limitations, contributions can be carried forward. So by and large it is pre-tax money, no? That’s what I have been doing for years.

Not a bad article, I prefer investing in stocks myself though instead of making the money managers rich. I like for ideas.

Also, TFSA can have a 100% equity allocation vs an RAs Regulation 28 ball and chain.

Over the 17 odd years of contributing, the 100% equity should outstrip the Reg 28 balance view.

And I disagree that an RA is pre-tax money. Yes, in theory it is, but hands up those who save the tax saving vs. just spending it.

Disagree – with a little discipline you contribute to a max equity RA fund with a low cost and then invest your tax rebate in a tax free savings account and invest 100% in stocks. there’s no way a taxable account will outperform the above especially not for high income earners

Load All 7 Comments
End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: