You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

NEW SENS search and JSE share prices

More about the app

Anglo’s coal spin-off Thungela debuts on JSE at R25

After short-seller Boatman Capital issued a report valuing Thungela at zero, due largely to what it says are underestimated rehabilitation costs.
Anglo says the regulations on which the Boatman report apparently draws its conclusion are ‘far from being finalised’. Image: VisMedia via Bloomberg News

Anglo American officially stepped out of the coal business on Monday when it spun off its remaining thermal coal assets into Thungela Resources, which debuted on the JSE at R25 a share.

Thungela Resources

Anglo investors received one Thungela share for every 10 Anglo shares held. Thungela holds 90% of Anglo’s thermal coal operations in SA, with the remaining 10% held collectively by employees and a community partnership.

Thungela listed with a net cash balance of R2.5 billion, with Anglo providing contingent capital support until the end of 2022 to offset any drop in coal prices, up to a maximum of $100 million in 2021 and $170 million in 2022.

The SA coal business produced 16.5 million tonnes (mt) of export coal and 12.4mt of domestic coal from seven coal mines with life spans of between three and 11 years. Cash costs were $38/t FOB (free on board) per saleable tonne and $51/t per export saleable tonne, placing the mines in the second quartile of the global energy adjusted seaborne cost curve, according to an analysis by Deutsche Bank. Exports account for about 80% of revenue.


Liberium estimates a valuation range of £2.30-£4.90 (R43-R93) a share, with value being driven by handsome dividend yields of 10-22%.

SBG Securities valued the shares at R33.

Deutsche values the group’s equity at $600-$900 million (R8-R12 billion).

Short-seller Boatman Capital released a report prior to the listing, arguing that there will be immediate pressure on Thungela’s share price once it lists. It expects the volume of sellers to exceed demand because of under-funded environmental liabilities that will increase once new environmental laws are introduced in SA.

Other factors weighing on the share price are investor migration, as Anglo shareholders received Thungela whether they wanted them or not.

Many may choose to exit the shares due to the associated risks, while investors remain wary of assets exposed to greenhouse gases. Boatman Capital also suggests Thungela may have overstated demand from Asia for its coal.

Why ‘zero’

Boatman argues that National Environment Management Authority (Nema) regulations could bump up environmental costs for Thungela nearly three times to R18.8 billion as opposed to the R6.45 billion provisioned by the company. On this basis it comes to a valuation of “less than zero” for the company.

“Putting it all together, we find the valuation of Thungela to be below zero,” says the Boatman report.

“We appreciate that any one adjustment is subject to debate but we prefer to be ‘roughly right rather than precisely wrong’ so cannot reach a valuation other than zero.”

Analysis contains ‘basic errors’ says Anglo

Anglo American replies that the Boatman analysis contains some basic errors, such as confusing metallurgical and thermal coal forecasts, and misreading the impact of new Nema regulations on environmental liabilities going forward.

“The provision of R6.45 billion on Thungela’s balance sheet is over and above the regulatory guidance for miners in South Africa, is in accordance with IFRS (International Financial Reporting Standards) and audited, and consistent with the provisioning norms within the industry,” says Anglo in response to the Boatman report.

“The basis for provisioning under SA’s draft Nema regulations simply does not accurately reflect the actual or likely sums needed to discharge such liabilities.

“It is precisely because these sums are considered to be artificial, and arbitrarily inflated, that the draft has remained under review since 2015.

“This is an industry-wide matter in SA, so the regulations on which the Boatman report apparently draws its conclusion are far from being finalised.”

Read: Anglo set out to reimagine mining, and the $2bn payoff has arrived (May 14)

Listen to Nompu Siziba’s interview with Thungela Resources CEO July Ndlovu (or read the transcript here):

Please consider contributing as little as R20 in appreciation of our quality independent financial journalism.



Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


Clearly Boatman have no clue about SA. This is a BEE initiative, rehabilitation will not be a priority and will NEVER cost 18 billion, perhaps in Germany yes not in SA. Buy this share up and teach these turkeys a lesson.

Isn’t this listed in London as well?

In my opinion Coal is here to stay, you cannot replace it with a flimsy wind turbine or hundreds of solar panels in the desert when it comes to heavy industry.

I suspect this is one of those reports to kill the share price and then someone snaps them up very cheap.

Do not get me wrong, I do support a green planet, but lets get real.

Seems that Boatman was very wrong about this share.

Where are the Boatmans people with their report?

They said thungela was worth 0 at listing.

In my opinion Boatmans are the laugh of the century. Where are they?

I’m getting so g@tvol with these smart @sses beating coal down, with the sheeple following them and bleating their words on wisdom around the braai fires. Yes, it is not a super green product but what is the alternative? The same sheeple baulk against nuclear, so what then? If you are so anti-coal, then put your money where your mouth is and stop using eskom (when available).

Seems to be the same for PGM(s), Gold is not that much down, Platinum, Palladium is still high priced, Iron ore has not really dropped that much.

Yet they are shorting resource shares.

If the Rand weakens or if there are local political problems, what would you want? paper (Rand) or Gold and metals which you can sell to the world markets for Dollars?

Plus Insurance companies have to pay for the Covid-19 deaths, the old Banks are sitting with debt write offs, yet they are pushing for Financial shares.

Coal ain’t going nowhere in Africa.

Not in my lifetime anyway.

Anglo just want to liquify the coal problem away.

Here we are 4 months later & Thungela is R100/share. Eina if they shorted.

End of comments.



Enter company name or share code:


  CPIThe Consumer Price Index (CPI) measures monthly changes in prices for a range of consumer products Sep 2021 5.00%
  CPI ex OERThe Consumer Price Index excluding Owners’ Equivalent Rent (CPI ex OER) measures monthly changes in prices for a range of consumer products excluding Owners’ equivalent rent that measures changes in the cost of owner-occupied housing Sep 2021 5.50%
  RepoThe rate at which the Reserve Bank lends money to the country’s commercial banks and set by the Reserve Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee. Oct 2021 3.50%
  Prime lendingThe Prime Lending Rate is the rate of interest that commercial banks will charge their clients when issuing a loan (home loan or vehicle finance) Oct 2021 7.00%

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: