You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

NEW SENS search and JSE share prices

More about the app

The hole in the jobs bucket

And the three dimensions of radical government transformation.
Picture: Shutterstock

SWELLENDAM – If you promised the government that you could create 48 000 new jobs in a few months they would dance at your feet. Yet, that is the number of jobs that were lost in the formal non-agricultural sector in the first quarter of this year, according to the latest Quarterly Employment Survey.

What it reflects is that counteracting all the efforts to create jobs, are those being lost where they exist – like filling a bucket that has a big hole. It underscores the fallacy of focusing on job creation rather than job retention and being caught in an endless spiral of creation and destruction. If you understand why jobs are being lost, you will know what prevents you from creating more. Job retention demands a shift in policies, approach, attitudes and behaviour at many levels – all of which imply sacrificing some vested interests and political capital. The main causes behind job losses are systemic and behavioural in both the public and private sectors, as well as a volatile external environment. In responding to this environment, the two indispensable, mutually supportive keys are flexibility and tempered expectations. 

Global financial headlines remind us daily of a world undergoing radical economic transformation. The anti-establishment uprising seen in many countries is challenging the legitimacy of both government and economic power and has blurred ideological divisions as well as theoretical prescriptions for the role of the state and the private sector, particularly capital concentration. For a long time, it seemed to have been a stunning omission of the ruling party, not to have connected these dots to its own radical economic transformation agenda, and instead made it a spectre and divisive project.

But that may have changed. The strategic outline delivered by ANC NEC member, Nathi Mthethwa at the policy conference, clearly reflected that insight and will hopefully transform the narrative to reflect:

  • The gravity and complexity of a global struggle for inclusivity and fragmentation of economic power; (see previous article here.)
  • The role South Africa can play in being an innovator, contributor and beneficiary of global experiences, which includes inputs from international economic thought leaders.
  • Eliminating race or gender as a contributing factor, albeit a feature (or as Mthethwa put it “form”) in South Africa. Burying the term “white monopoly capital” is a good start.
  • And above all – the need for power fragmentation in both government and the private sector as a key factor for flexibility.

The last point is the difficult one for governments not only to recognise, but willingness to return power to the people in a real and tangible form. The concept that governments represent all of the people, all of the time, is patent nonsense – even more so in a state where bureaucracy is often driven by self-gratification and power. If fragmentation of economic power simply means transferring power from private hands to government, then on the evidence of both historic and current experience, it will be the greater of two evils.

It is the outcome of that debate that will profoundly affect inclusivity, flexibility and expectations, and the ability to both retain and create new jobs. Although mutually linked, the approaches are different for government and the private sector. This article deals with the former, and a future column will examine the latter.

I am more convinced than ever that radical government transformation has to go hand in hand with RET and can do far more in changing the economic destiny of the country. The fact that we are suffering from economic pneumonia because the ruling party has a Gupta virus, points to a self-evident truth: the inordinate influence, invasiveness and power of bureaucracy. It is excessive even for a developmental state and because of that one can reach another simple conclusion: its bears a large share of responsibility for whatever ails the country. This power has three dimensions:

Physical size and share of the economy. Globally, governments have become “fat and lazy”, according to economist, Dawie Roodt. With our government expenditure at about one third of GDP we are not among the most obese (see World Bank statistics here), and not totally out of line with the world average. Ultimately, size does not matter. It is about affordability and action. We are worse than lazy. There is deeply-rooted and debilitating patronage; an oversized cabinet and employee contingent; poor and incoherent leadership; scandals; inefficiencies; flawed service delivery; wasteful expenditure, and corruption. The belief that government must be as small as possible to avoid crowding out private initiative is an oversimplification and not a universal truth. What really counts is whether its actions support private initiative, while still countering social imbalances.

Prescriptions and regulations. These have far greater impact than can be measured in standard statistics. Even a superficial analysis of all bureaucratic impediments is beyond the scope of this article. Even less so, and perhaps more futile, is challenging some of the regulatory holy cows to “correct past imbalances”, and the counter-productive effect they have had on inclusivity and employment. It simply makes no sense to focus on inclusion of one group and discourage others that may have skills, experience and capital and whose deployment encourages further job creation. One recent example is the proposed new Mining Charter which the industry estimates could see as many as 100 000 job losses.

Political posturing and populist rhetoric. When you have become as powerful and invasive as the South African government has, you simply have to watch your mouth and actions. I would argue that this now overshadows all of the above. You will find the footprint of rhetoric and irrational decisions in most of our recent economic setbacks, including an undervalued currency, disinvestment and ratings downgrades. They are triggered by a loose cannon in the president who does not distinguish between a parliamentary democracy and constitutionalism; a ruling party in meltdown; threatening and divisive interpretations of land reform and expropriation, and constant deflective racial innuendo. Even the more comical kite fliers such as the Public Protector on monetary policy, have a serious impact on economic prosperity. Market response to an ill-informed policy discussion about Reserve Bank ownership is another example. The burying of the term “white monopoly capital” may be a reflection of growing sensitivity towards this third dimension. Clearly much more has to be done to change the mood.

A huge, ominous and potentially overwhelming cloud remains. Despite all the arguably good intentions of ANC policy, and a fall back to the more palatable National Development Plan, there is still a massive lack of trust. Trustworthiness is an imperative even for autocratic governments; not only from its supporters but also from its opponents, critics and society at large. The government’s critically large trust deficit (see graphic here) is now at centre stage. It is perhaps even beyond redemption. Opponents may hail this as an opportunity for regime change, but distrust is contagious and not easily restored even after a change in leadership or government. It is also a significant contributor to the hole in the jobs bucket.

It is that which needs radical attention.

Oops! We could not locate your form.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


the saying “hope springs eternal in the human breast” should be tattooed on mr Schuitema’s chest (excuse the pun)for all to marvel AT his eternal optimism that “alles sal regkom”. when are commentators going to wake up that ALLES SAL NIE REGKOM NIE and start making plans for the calamity that is about to engulf the country. speak to yr friends in hout bay abt facing up to reality

South Africa has been a “frontier nation” since 1652. Constant skirmishes with the Koi, stock-theft, dangerous animals and walking into the firing line of the British Army was part of daily life. Some chose to move north to face regular attacks by the locals, some so intense that rivers ran red with blood. The constant threat of lions, leopard, crocodile, buffalo, rhino and snakes made life a battle. To make things exponentially worse, the Queen of the “most civilized” nation on earth sent her troops to kill locals and lock women and children in concentration camps where most died.

Now, Robert, are you serious when you say that things are going to get worse? Things have never been this good. Australia is a retirement village for the tired and boring. South Africa is vibrant. The same person that cleans and protects our houses and feeds our children during the day, while we are at work, burns the post-office on her way home. This has always been a frontier nation.

do you want to repeat “Things have never been this good” at ANY shanty town in the country – esp those living above the palatial homes of hout bay. “You have eyes–can’t you see? You have ears–can’t you hear?’ Don’t you remember anything at all?”

@Sensei, yours is the comment of 2017!! I too live in this frontier nation, and as I look out my window at the coming winter rain clouds over Chapman’s Peak, I am so excited about this place we live in! I can smell the opportunity in the air, yes the danger too, but I never feel as alive as when I return to these beautiful shores, I am proud to call this place home…

Robert do you suggest that those very shanty town people or their ancestors once lived in mansions/ middle income homes? In some respect I have to disagree with Sensei that live has never been this good. Crime has significantly deteriorated since 1900. Back in 1900 2 murders per 100 000 people versus 36 today. Poisoning through food and the environment and pollution is at an all time high. Cancer, and autism is more prevalent than ever before. Unemployment at an all time high. The things that has improved are medicine and technology, but most of which were developed in other countries.

Dear robertinsydney:
I’ve been reading Moneyweb for a number of years now and usually gloss over your continual carping, small-minded and vituperative comments about the South African situation.

We have enough to deal with on a daily basis without your sad, self-absorbed input, so I’m asking Moneyweb to ban your comments, cancel your account if you have one and from probably all of their readers.

So Beachcomber, the minute somebody gets up your nose, the intelligent response is to BAN them from your presence? Simply because YOU don’t LIKE what they say?

This is schoolboy playground behaviour. And just as indefensible!

Imagine if everybody adopted this attitude with listening to anybody else? Wars have started because of this silliness. And the scourge of our modern times – religious terrorism – is DIRECTLY founded on this thinking. Not Good! At all.

Very often in life, the very reason why you DON’T want to listen to the other person is EXACTLY the reason why you SHOULD be listening to them.

And this doesn’t just apply to Bob.

It applies to EVERYBODY you encounter who has a different background or view to yours. From family, to co-workers, to customers. No exceptions.

The reason Bob irritates you so much lies inside YOU – not Bob.

Very good analysis by Jerry. Very useful to make the point that the real radical economic transformation is taking place internationally. Those with a level of education that is insufficient to cope with the international RET, will have difficulty in coping.

Time to replace communist educated cadres in government with real entrepeneurs and professional people who will make the correct and long lasting economic decisions regarding the economy which basically is ”less governance is best governance”- stay the hell out of businesses way !

End of comments.



Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: