You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App
Join our mailing list to receive top business news every weekday morning.

Don’t let the taxman tax you twice

How a Double Taxation Agreement could provide relief to South Africans working abroad.
Picture: Moneyweb

Come March 1 2019, every South African working abroad may be taxed in South Africa on their foreign employment income.

If you are a 25% taxpayer in the foreign country, those equivalent earnings in South Africa would be subject to 45% tax. The foreign worker may then face a further tax bill of 20% in South Africa.

However, South Africans working abroad can claim the relief of a Double Taxation Agreement (DTA).

They would have to obtain a certificate of tax residency from the overseas country, and the onus rests on them to prove that they meet the criteria of the DTA’s definitions.

A South African working abroad may escape the proposed amendment if:

  • You’re not deemed to be ordinarily resident in South Africa;
  • You’re deemed to be resident in your foreign country by virtue of the provisions of a double taxation agreement.

The amendments to section 10(1)(o)(ii) of the Income Tax act were published on July 2o, and the Taxation Laws Amendment Bill was published for comment and is open until August 18.

While Pravin Gordhan in his 2017 budget proposed tax on foreign employment income where such income was not subject to tax in the foreign country, the bill proposes a complete repeal of the exemption. This has the direct implication that all South Africans working abroad may be taxed in South Africa on their foreign employment income, subject to any off set of foreign tax paid.

It must be stressed though that this would not apply to all South Afrians working abroad.

South Africa has a residence-based system of taxation, so in general the government is able to tax your worldwide income if you are ordinarily resident in South Africa or meet the requirements of the physical presence test.

Many South Africans working abroad may still be deemed to be ordinarily resident in South Africa.

If you’re not deemed to be an ordinarily resident in South Africa, the proposed changes to the act would not affect you. The onus is on you to demonstrate this fact to the South African Revenue Servicw.

How a DTA could could provide taxation relief

Most DTAs contain specific provisions on the definition of a resident in order to settle which of the two countries (where a person may be seen to be resident in both countries) has the primary taxing rights over such person.

These are the so-called tie-breaker rules used to determine the tax residency of an individual where he or she may be deemed resident in two countries based on local legislation.

Once a person is found to be a resident of the overseas state in respect of a DTA, he is regarded to be sole resident in that state for taxation purposes. Thus, even if a South African working abroad may be deemed to be ordinarily resident in South Africa by virtue of the provisions of the Income Tax Act, if he meets the criteria in terms of the relevant DTA, he may be deemed solely a resident of the overseas state.

The proposed repeal of the exemption would not have any effect either, subject to that such individual complying with the relevant article dealing with employment income contained in such a DTA.

Mike Abbott is director at Sable International.

Oops! We could not locate your form.

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


Is South Africa intending to cancel the Double Taxation agreements they have with other countries? They cannot have their cake and eat it too.

They want to cancel the Rome Statute Agreement. They want to change lots of agreements to suit themselves. If they mess with the tax agreements they have with other countries, then they must expect other countries not to comply with the agreements which they have entered into with South Africa. This could also have other countries not give South Africa banking info if it means that the person is being disadvantaged in his new country or in the country he is working in. I think this idea is going to backfire big time.

All this because the taxes they collected they stole, and now they need more money from those who are paying taxes because they are greedy. hey have all got their snouts in the feeding trough.

Yelelele! More free money for the ANC!

I’ve emigrated …

I feel sorry for anybody who has not.

Yet here you are, commenting on Moneyweb. Good for you!

I’ve emigrated too. I just come here for the comments.

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: