You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App
Join our mailing list to receive top business news every weekday morning.

Lessons from the elections: Adapt or die

SA’s political parties are at a crossroads.
The elections exposed the weaknesses of the various parties and highlighted their disconnect from many of the people they assumed were supporting them. Picture: Waldo Swiegers/Bloomberg

South Africa’s election season has come to an end and the country must be applauded for carrying it out successfully. Watched by African and international observers, South Africa has demonstrated that notwithstanding obvious differences, robust electioneering and numerous political parties, it is able to hold free and fair elections.

There are worrying signs though; a low voter turn out and specifically those missing voters within the youth demographic. For many South Africans who stayed away, their actions demonstrate the increasing indifference to politicians and their empty promises.

Can you blame them? They know too well the lies politicians tell. Consider the residents of Alexandra, who have for more than 20 years been promised better living conditions in the form of houses, sanitation and infrastructure. Many are still on the waiting list for government houses.

South Africa is desperate for a leadership that will rebuild the economy and society. A leadership that is aware that progress, jobs, a stable labour market and modernisation are essential to the vitality of its people and the greater nation.

A leadership that realises in order to achieve economic growth, it must encourage investment. 

Returning to politics, we have witnessed how these elections have not only proved difficult for the voters, they have also revealed uncomfortable truths to parties regarding their status and organisational weakness. The coinciding decline of the ANC and the DA, contrasted with the below- expectations growth of the EFF, are intriguing, telling and yet unsurprising developments with far-reaching and unique consequences for these parties.

The ANC: shaken, but will it be stirred?

The support the ANC has enjoyed since the advent of democracy is waning and shaken. On top of that, it is proving to be devoid of freshness and has an entrenched problem of political leaders who have been in government and politics for so long they may be reluctant to envision change.

The party must undergo a makeover of its leaders and break the perceptions that they’ve created. The results for Gauteng reflect the seriousness of the ANC’s crisis. Were there to emerge a credible and attractive opposition, its hold on power would fail and lead to the end of its era.

The party may have won the elections, however, its biggest hurdle is itself. Will this victory bring about real change or the illusion of it?

There is no doubt that DA leader Mmusi Maimane’s political career now hangs on a knife’s edge. The DA’s poor showing will have his opponents calling for his head, arguing that doubt about his leadership has been proven true. Does he still have enough support internally to withstand the challenge? That remains to be seen.

These elections have shown that having a black face in charge is not enough and does not translate to resonance with black voters. Evidently, it also did not sit well with some white supporters who voted for VF Plus.

The crisis of the DA may not be as apparent as that of the ANC, but it is similar in that it is a party struggling to contemplate change. Worse, it is riddled with the fear that it might alienate its white supporters. The hollowness he once spoke of has come to haunt Maimane and the DA.

Social media versus real life

We tend to forget, the enthusiasm and political cult of youth does not offer value for voters. More importantly, populism in the age of social media does not mean the same in real life. However, the youth also bring energy and willingness to do things differently and ignite change.

For some, the EFF’s growth is underwhelming because it has not given the party the coveted kingmaker’s role. Its leader, Julius Malema, is the sort of man who commands attention. That is partly, no doubt, because he has managed to embody the essence of a Machiavellian politician – cunning and adaptable, with the ability to survive.

What these elections have revealed about the red party is that it will have to come up with a new approach. Its change in direction must reflect the challenges faced by a society in an ever-changing globalised economy.

It is hard for voters who did not vote for the EFF to believe that the party can bring about change. Although appearing to make the right noises and offer sound propositions, voters denied the party that 15%. Was it a case of dislike, distrust or low turn out? The next elections will no doubt tell.

The lessons from this year’s elections are that political parties must adapt or reinvent themselves. Otherwise they will find little or no support from the country’s dynamic populace. The UDM, COPE and the PAC epitomise this.

The elections have also exposed the political parties’ weaknesses and disconnect from many people they assumed were supporting them. That is another simple lesson – parties have failed to show ordinary citizens that they’re paying attention to their worries and have solutions for them.
Have they learned? Sometimes simple lessons are the hardest to learn or implement. The next elections will indeed be telling. 

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.



Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


Nice article. It’s high time we get a political party that drops ideology for practical ideas that will work and do some good.

When kick starting the Chinese economic revolution Deng Xiaoping said ” It doesn’t matter if a cat is black or white, so long as it catches mice.”

It’s time for our Deng moment.

Agreed. Jou lekker Dêng 😉

South Africa’s future direction will become clearer over the next 6-12 months.
The time for talking and making empty promises is clearly over for all South Africans. We cannot continue one more day on the corrupt low road. We need sweeping changes and strong leadership that will benefit and improve the lives of all South Africans not just the corrupt and ruling elite both in Government and Corporate South Africa.
My bet is that our President will set South Africa up on the high road and defy all his sceptics making South Africa great.
Lets wait and see what transpires, but at least lets give our President a chance to do what he needs to

“South Africa is desperate for a leadership that will rebuild the economy and society.”

Oh really? Seems like the opposite is true judging by the growth in the EFF.

The EFF got almost 6 times less votes than the ANC, they are a small fly on the back of the hippo.

The voting patterns are getting worse.

Reality, the DA is the only party that has delivered acceptable results in the country in the WC. too early to call how their JHB project is going but they might not stay in the office there long enough for it to matter.

EFF, thugs who promise pie in the sky whilst probably stealing, slightly more aggressive and racist ANC basically.

And then there’s the ANC, I saw Ace talking after the win, a reporter asked him why he thinks the ANC has lost black votes. His answer was that it was because black voters have to walk to voting stations whilst white voters drive there. Nothing is going to change at the ANC, they do not have the capacity or willpower to do so.

So ultimately, the same sinking ship presents itself and the 70% odd who voted for these two parties deserve it.

Is it not the ideal time for a Clem Sunter type scenario presentation, to be seen by all notable decision makers in the country?

In the mid eighties Clem Sunter presented the two options for SA – the High Road and the Low Road scenario. If SA took the Low Road it would have led to disaster. We have elements of both scenarios.

Now that the politics is out of the way, we can start rebuilding the country and do what successful countries do – focus on high economic growth and low population growth.

End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be cancelled at any time.

Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: