You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App
Join our mailing list to receive top business news every weekday morning.

Ramaphosa’s education plans don’t quite make the grade

The speech scored an A for its vision and plan for economic renewal, but an F for education.
Infrastructural problems at schools should have been sorted out a decade ago and the focus should now be on substantive educational issues. Picture: Shutterstock

South African President Cyril Ramaphosa’s State of the Nation Address, delivered in Cape Town on February 7, has attracted a fair amount of praise. But while the speech scored an A for its vision and plan for economic renewal, it scored an F for education.

If the amount of time spent on a topic during the speech is any indication of where the president’s priorities lie, then those concerned about South Africa’s education system –- at all levels –- have reason to be concerned. Early on, he listed “improving education” as one of the government’s five most urgent tasks, but he didn’t elaborate on this point until well into his second hour of speaking. In fact, more time was given to tourism than education.

One can appreciate that the president had many pressing points to make about the country’s dysfunctional parastatals, and weeding out corruption. It’s likely that the audience he was most concerned about were potential foreign investors, not ordinary citizens concerned about the safety of their children on university campuses after a week of protests or those who worry about the quality of basic education.

But it would have been good to hear Ramaphosa use his brief time at the podium to give a considered, thoughtful – and sobering – assessment of the state of South Africa’s entire education system. He could have acknowledged that, after 25 years as a democracy, the country’s education system hasn’t yet turned the corner from deep dysfunctionality to sustained success. And this critical assessment should have been accompanied by a strategy to map the way forward.

Basic education

Instead, Ramaphosa spoke of his government’s commitment to basic infrastructural backlogs, such as toilets. Ensuring that schools have basic infrastructure in place is critical. But the fact that the president had to raise this as an issue at all is a shame to the minister of basic education. Ramaphosa made similar promises in his 2018 State of the Nation Address about school infrastructure development which the department of basic education hasn’t delivered on.

These infrastructural problems should have been sorted out a decade ago especially given that the department has been taken to court to make it happen. The focus now should be on substantive educational issues. It would have been important to hear the president comment on South Africa’s ongoing challenges in producing school leavers who are qualified for first year university mathematics.

The president also created a fanfare by announcing the rollout of e-tablets for all school children. If he sincerely believes that access to this form of technology is one of South Africa’s most pressing problems, he has been badly advised by his minister. Technology is a merely a tool for teaching and learning. If the teaching and learning experience is poor for a variety of reasons, access to a tablet will make no difference.

Where are the country’s skills going to come from to compete in the fourth industrial revolution? Probably not from giving pupils access to e-tablets when the principles of basic numeracy are still not properly taught.

Higher education

With respect to the technical and vocational education and training sector, Ramaphosa echoed the same promises that have been made before, vowing to build up this sector so it can contribute to the development of technically skilled graduates. No one will disagree with this.

But what should have been discussed was the progress or lack thereof that has been made in the past five years to strengthen this important sector. This was among the former Minister of the Department of Higher Education and Training’s priorities, and is high on the current Minister’s list, too. So: what progress has there been on their watch?

The week leading up to Ramaphosa’s speech saw student protests erupt on a number of university campuses. One protest ended in tragedy: Mlungisi Madonsela, a student at the Durban University of Technology, was shot dead – allegedly by a security guard hired to protect the campus. Ramaphosa acknowledged both the protests and Madonsela’s death.

But the sector urgently needed some stabilising assurances. Will the promise of “free education” for the poorest be delivered on now and in the future? Is the state thinking beyond the current crises to issues of financial sustainability for the future? What happens to academically eligible students whose National Student Financial Aid Scheme funding runs out after four years?

Finally, Ramaphosa rightly lauded the achievements of the Square Kilometre Array, which will be the world’s largest radio telescope when it’s completed in the mid-2020s.

But the reality is that sustaining this kind of research will require investment in South African universities’ research capacity. It would have been good if the President had acknowledged the deplorable conditions of research funding in universities and the huge risk this presents to the country unless it is addressed. Academics and the public need to know that this is on the President’s radar – and, specifically, how this trend will be reversed.

Overall, the president failed to convince ordinary South Africans that education – arguably one of the most important contributors to a thriving society – is in good hands.The Conversation

Suellen Shay, Professor, University of Cape Town

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


An A for its vision and plan for economic renewal? Really?

I think I was watching a different SONA.

Perhaps an A in fairytale story telling?

Amazing that education gets left behind when it is such a critical tool for shaping the future economy but gets ignored again and again. It’s not an overnight job for sure, it will take a decade or two to get the output of big investment today but it is futile planning a future with a fast growing uneducated pooor population, what manufactoring jobs are they goign to work on to get basic skills, what mining equipment will they be able to operate etc etc…

Maybe there is a big plan somewhere I am aware of but if you want to us tablet then use them, get a centralized SA based teacher program that teaches in native languages in early years, don’t however just hand out tablets and wait..

I think the last thing the ANC wants is an educated populous.

…a “G” in Woodwork perhaps?

ANC / EFF policy…educated people will not vote for them

Oh calm down everyone! There’s an election coming soon!!!

Free land! Free education! Free e-tablets! As someone commented this is like Oprah except that there’s no $100 bill under your chair.

Has anyone told them that iPads need to be charged with electricity – that commodity we often don’t have ! Having been involved with schools previously, the one guarantee is that the iPads will be stolen left, right and Centre. Before iPads, get the basics right such as decent facilities, decent teachers and a lot more discipline. When these are in place and running smoothly, then you can look at ramping up the technology. Until then, it is merely a pipe dream.

The wife and I have been teaching at an orphanage for about 3 years. Many of the kids do not read or write. In my humble experience (don’t laugh) we get the very best results initial with an abacus. From there on we go onto laptops and CAMI for math. But a pre requisite is a dedicated committed teacher. Just handing out I Pads will not contribute anything. Until the SADTU is brought to heel, nothing will change.

Municipalities in tatters!
SOE’s in tatters!
Health Care in tatters!
Education in tatters!
Only the ANC is intact and will win the elections with EMPTY promises.

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: