Transforming the agricultural sector

The potential of smallholder farmers needs to be unlocked.
Innovation in agriculture as well as access to credit are some of the important factors smallholder farmers need to move beyond subsistence farming, Eckstein writes. Picture: Supplied

The South African government believes that the key to food security lies in investing in smallholder agriculture and has committed to pumping R5.5 billion of the national budget to support 435 000 subsistence and smallholder farmers over the next three years[i]. The government has also committed itself to expand the 200 000 smallholder producers who sell their produce to 500 000 smallholders by 2020.[ii]

In fact, according to South Africa’s development blueprint, the National Development Plan, agriculture is a significant sector in the South African economy and has the potential to create close to one million new jobs by 2030.[iii] Smallholder farmers are expected to play a significant role in this, both in terms of poverty alleviation and rural development for South Africa’s rural economies and moreover contribute to the sustainability of food supply. The key to this is to get smallholder farmers to become commercially viable by creating return on investment which can be invested to grow their farming practices.

Read: Africa’s economic future depends on its farmers

It is also important to note that agriculture contributed 33.6% to the GDP growth of 2.5% in the second quarter, helping the economy to emerge from a technical recession, following GDP contractions over two consecutive quarters earlier this year.

Read: SA economy recovers from recession in second quarter

With close to 30 million South Africans said to be poor and living below the poverty line on less than R1 000 a month according to Stats SA, corporate South Africa must play its part in boosting the country’s food security and poverty alleviation efforts. At Bayer Southern Africa, we are using new business-based approaches to help tackle a myriad of challenges facing smallholder farmers daily.

We know that smallholder farmers’ challenges impede their growth and ability to effectively contribute to food security relative to commercial farmers. They need to be equipped with the ability to better identify opportunities for increased agricultural production. To this end, we have implemented more than a dozen initiatives focused on smallholder farmers, largely in Africa and Asia.

Read: Poor nations need farm investment or face importing more food

The focus of our initiative is two-fold: To provide education to smallholders on best management practices, pest and disease management, and how to establish better links in order to market their harvest. Second, to implement specific initiatives tailored to meet local market needs, including the development of food chain partnerships and collaborative initiatives with public institutions.

Fundamentally, we believe these initiatives should be driven by commercial rather than solely  by charity or philanthropic considerations if they are to be sustainable and impactful in the long term. The significance of the smallholder farmer cannot be underestimated and will become even more important in the future.

Maryam Rahmanian, vice-chairperson of the Food and Agriculture Organisation’s High-Level Panel of Experts on Food Security and Nutrition Committee, has been quoted as saying that prior to the 2008 food price crisis, smallholder agriculture was seen as a problem that kept countries in a backward state. Farmers were told to “get big or get out”. This is no longer the case, according to Rahmanian.

Over the past few years, smallholder farmers’ contribution to food production, growth, stability and security has been recognised as significant. There are currently more than 500 million smallholder farms worldwide, most of which are still dependent on natural rainfall for crop irrigation.

Although the term smallholder refers to all farms with less than two hectares, there are significant differences within the farm operations in this category. In total, there are three categories of smallholders:

  • Professional smallholders (around 5%, using many of the most modern techniques)
  • Developing or emerging smallholders
  • Subsistence smallholders

Our studies have shown that by focusing on the requirements and aspirations of farmers in the developing/emerging categories, we can have the most significant impact on farmers’ livelihoods, their further development to commercialisation and contribution to food production overall. This is because our work at local level, in the field of education as well as inputs towards healthy crops can have rapid, demonstrable and scalable effects and can be used as a catalyst to encourage further development among these and other smallholder farmers, and have the effect of an increase in yields.

This is crucial, especially in the context of the land restitution process, with land reform beneficiaries increasingly abandoning their newly acquired farms due to the lack of necessary experience, skills and support to make a success of them. Our numerous local initiatives are the starting point for a step-change in the lives of smallholder farmers, recognising the fundamentally important role that they have currently and will increasingly have in our future food production.

Importantly, we also recognise that the needs of the smallholder farmer extend past the full cycle of agricultural production. Access to credit, selection of the right seeds, agricultural know-how, land preparation and seeding, management of water, energy and soil, pest, disease and weed control, harvesting and storage, and access to market are all important factors that smallholder farmers need to be familiar with if they want to move beyond subsistence farming alone.

Our experience globally has shown that innovation in farming inputs is undoubtedly a major driver to increase crop quality and productivity and has proven to be one of the most decisive ways to increase the income and development of smallholders.

It is up to all the stakeholders involved in the local agricultural sector to come together to unlock the very real potential that exists in the smallholder farming sector in South Africa and Africa overall. 

Dr Klaus Eckstein is the CEO and country divisional head of the Crop Science Division for Bayer Southern Africa.

Oops! We could not locate your form.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


In the district where I live farmers have a saying “If you give a farm of less than 1200 ha to your son, and expect him to make a living, you are guilty of child abuse”. Smallholder farming is the panacea for the politician and economical suicide by attrition for the farmer.

The smallholder farmer is basically competing with the “low prices” at Shoprite. If you bet against Whitey Basson you are either ill-informed or stupid.

If past history is anything to go by – S.A. will starve.
These “small scale farmers” dont know how to farm. Farming is a skill and not everyone given a tract of land (or wanting a tract of land) can farm.
The Governments experiments in giving away valuable productive farms (after being paid for by the taxpayer) have all been a disaster.
Political ideology does not feed a starving nation – just look at once thriving economies north of our borders.

As a farmer I more than welcome this initiative, and we as established farmers are more than happy to help. But please don’t ask for help and threaten to take our ground in the same sentence. It took us generations of good and bad years to get where we are and you need to realize it will take these new farmers also generations to get up and running and stable.

Farming is not for sissies, it is ultra high risk and damn hard work.

Damn hard work. You can say that again. My uncle is a maize farmer. Gets up at 4am every morning and works till 7pm.

ja it is sometimes 18 hr days and weekends??? Won’t even talk about that while lambing and calving.

Once upon a time, probably till the early 2000’s, South African had many substistence farmers in the rural areas, men and women who knew what they were doing and were relatively successful at it.
Then came the era of child grants etc, people had more cash at their disposal to buy more store-based food, so those skills weren’t passed on to the next generation.

Of course commercial and subsistence farming differ vastly, but at least those oldies had an idea.
Giving a farm to someone who knows bugger-all, just won’t end well.

The article is nothing new to the industry. I agree with the stumbling blocks i.e. access to credit, markets, supply of inputs etc.
The important thing for me is that there needs to be formal skills transfer from existing successful commercial farmers to small-scale farmers.
It is noble to say that small-scale farmers’ potential must be unlocked, but without mentor ship, it will not be a success.
Access to credit is hampered by availability of assets as security, own contributions etc.
If big commercial farmers get involved by way of JVs with these farmers, skills can be transferred. Farming is a business and not only technical skills are required, but also managerial and financial skills.
It will remain a challenge unless formal action plans/structures can be put in place

GPG I mentored a farm in the district where I farm. I gave up after about 2 months as the owners/tenants decided they would work if and when they wanted to. As I did not employ them I could not set work hours so what started quite well with a 6.30am meeting and discussion eventually fizzled out. No one was arriving so I let the department know that it was a waste of time.

One place where there is thriving small scale agriculture taking place is in Phillipi Cape Town. Instead of supporting this the authorities are rezoning this prime agricultural land and selling it off to property developers. Where will Cape Town get its veggies from in the future? – flown in from Kenya I suppose.

End of comments.



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Moneyweb newsletters

Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: