You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

NEW SENS search and JSE share prices

More about the app

The charade that could be the budget

Is Gigaba the right person to open his arms in supplication saying: ‘gimme’?
Minister of Finance Malusi Gigaba will deliver the budget on February 21. Picture: Bloomberg

In 2017 Minister of Finance Pavin Gordhan was flanked by Deputy Minister Mcebisi Jonas and Director-General Lungile Fuzile, striding towards Parliament to deliver the budget Speech. There was much to do.

This year, who will it be?

After all, the sorry state of South Africa’s economy will have to be revealed, in particular:

  • The depth of the fiscal under collection (Will the commissioner of Sars, Tom Moyane, be seated in the upper gallery waiting for the nod of thanks and appreciation from the minister?);
  • The amount of capital required to keep those insolvent state-owned entities afloat (regular emergency handouts are so amateurish);
  • The innovative plan to fund free tertiary education (the student leaders should be in the gallery. They do after all represent our future);
  • An increase in the paltry sum inefficiently given to the poor;
  • The rumoured state sponsorship of Jacob Zuma’s protection and legal fees;
  • The plan as to how all this additional revenue will be raised.

Meanwhile, we have been subjected to another year of corruption and maladministration of public institutions and state-owned entities, wasteful and irregular expenditure, the hovering controlling presence of the Gupta cephalopod, and bullying by Sars (hence, the tax-paying public is currently rather prickly and unsupportive).

For whatever reason, Sars has dismally failed as the tax collector. The only question that remains is by how much.

Obviously certain taxes need to be raised, new taxes may be introduced, and certain incentives may have to be cut. This will hit taxpayers hard. Raising Vat will be devastating to the poor. And all this has to be accomplished between National Treasury and Sars, with their ever dwindling supply of knowledgeable staff.

Somewhat trickier, changes require legislation to be written, systems to be changed, and Sars’s staff to administer the changes. Let me not forget the training. There are very few staff left at Sars who are capable of running training courses, and these are generally the top specialists, who should be bringing in the money…

Notwithstanding the above hurdles, the budget should offer solutions to the low skills base, creation of jobs, high unemployment, low business confidence and the lack of fixed investment. There should be an update on the recommendations of the president’s committees, established at the time of the Medium-Term Budget. The purpose of the committee was to make hard decisions. Did they?

The budget should also address those government departments who are wasting state resources and not providing the services. Why does parliament not have a rogue’s gallery for those ministers who have not delivered?

Given his checkered past, his links to the Gupta brotherhood and alleged hand in state capture (refer to Betrayal of the Promise), his restructuring of SOE boards as Minister of Public Enterprises, is Gigaba really the right person to open his arms in supplication saying: “gimme”?

Let us forever pay homage to Nelson Mandela, and never forget his promise on behalf of the newly-elected ANC government in 1994: “ …to liberate all our people from the continuing bondage of poverty, deprivation, suffering, gender and other discrimination… to build a society in which all South Africans, both black and white, will be able to walk tall, without any fear in their hearts, assured of their inalienable right to human dignity – a rainbow nation at peace with itself and the world”.

This budget should be the start of new beginnings, a country triumphantly rising out of the fetid depths of state capture, and backed by its citizens, investors and taxpayers. Then we can face the world and state: “We are open for business and you will want to do business with us”.




Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


“The lady doth protest too much, methinks” as hamlet would have said!!!why can’t people just accept that sa is (or will soon to be) a failed state. be grateful for what you have – which us ex japies cannot enjoy – cheap domestic help – easy access to your family – being the two that I can think of immediately . the country is a mess and will take a long time to get over the nine bad years of zuma and the 360 years of racial separation.

Sober Assessment. Yes, we should to take time to be grateful for lots of things we take for granted. But as humans, we will never be satisfied.

Hopefully we have a president that leads us to dream of a rainbow nation. The road is not rosy; but we’ll get there.

Indeed Rob, SA is (or will soon be) a failed state. Hence, congratulations sir for making the correct decision to move to Oz in the 80’s. All happy now?

Then I sense disdain towards Africa and its people (the same group of people you sympathize with, the voiceless masses) by simply implying this country (or Africa for that matter) is “a mess”. Most African states must then be failed states to some degree, some more than others. You should know that this is the way Africa operate & please have respect for African people’s way of life, and their views. To Western standards any African country is viewed as a failed state, while to Africans used to that over centuries, it’s accepted as the norm / our way of life. The continent we love. It’s disrespectful to view the way African people choose to live, as “a mess”. We are NOT a mess. We’re an African country. Need to accept that. Blessings from wild Africa 🙂

Spot on, Michael. There seem to be two general kinds of expats from SA: those who spend hours online reading all they can to confirm that its going down the tubes and justifying their decision to move (like Rob). They also justify their move by telling all their new pals overseas how bad it is in SA. The second general grouping are those who left but still have one foot back in Africa: those who want it to go well because all the people they love live there. They seem to hope to come back one day. Sure we have problems, sure its complex, sure its tough. But SA is a country full of wonderful, talented people and now finally we have some hope. Rob: at some time you need to cut the umbilical cord and make peace with your new found happiness in safe, happy, prosperous, white Australia. “Always with the negative vibes, Moriarty ” (Oddball in Kelly’s Heroes, one of my favourite quotes of all time).

Its interesting Rob’s last vacation was to Africa….. just to confirm how bad it is here?

ps the mention of cheap domestic help is so inane it doesn’t actually deserve a comment. It is the last reason to live in SA. And most of us help put their kids through school, help the domestic build a house and subsidize transport which eats up their salary. We help where we can.

Then get your chicken ..t butt back here and help rebuild the nation, sunshine, otherwise your opinion is just that, a wothless opinion from afar.

With respect, it’s never Gigiba’s budget, he just reads what his minions and backroom boys wrote, if last year is anything to go by.

End of comments.



Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: