Join Moneyweb Editor Ryk van Niekerk, economists Dr Iraj Abedian and Isaah Mhlanga and tax practitioner Yolandi Esterhuizen on Thursday, February 25 at 11h00 in a free webinar analysing the budget. Registration is essential.

[TOP STORY] Is Tesla overpriced relative to other car companies?

‘If Tesla gets self-driving right, I think that is something that could justify this kind of price’ – Viv Govender of Rand Swiss.

SIMON BROWN: I’m chatting now with Viv Govender, he is, of course, a portfolio manager at Rand Swiss. Viv, good morning. I appreciate your time. Later today, I think after the close in the US, [we’ll get] Tesla results. I’m reminded of a conversation we had around Tesla, and I’m trying to remember when it was. I think it was in August or September. At that point, split-adjusted it was (around) $300 a share and, in fact, looking at the chart, it goes back earlier. It was early August. It’s now rallied to $880-odd dollars. It is on a price/earnings of crazy numbers. 

Moneyweb Insider INSIDERGOLD

Subscribe for full access to all our share and unit trust data tools, our award-winning articles, and support quality journalism in the process.

Choose an option:

R63 per month
R630 per year SAVE R126

You will be redirected to a checkout page.
To view all features and options, click here.

A monthly subscription is charged pro rata, based on the day of purchase. This is non-refundable and includes a R5 once-off sign-up fee.
A yearly subscription is refundable within 14 days of purchase and includes a 365-day membership.

Click here for more information.

You made the argument when we spoke last time that this has been valued more like a tech stock, and certainly, that is what the pricing is telling us. But this stock is pricing in a bright future, plus a lot more.

VIV GOVENDER: Yes. If you’ve valued Tesla as a car company, it’s impossible to value it at this level. There’s just no way to get a valuation this high. If it was the world’s best, biggest car company, if you look at other car companies out there, the Toyotas, the Volkswagens, much, much larger companies, that do production in terms of sales, revenue, and so on, Tesla’s valuation is multiples what theirs are. And so the only way to get a valuation of this, for Tesla, is if you value it as a tech company, and if you focus on one particular aspect of it, I believe, which is the self-driving option. 

If Tesla gets self-driving right, I think that is something that could justify this kind of price, because that is something that will actually change quite frankly, the way the world functions. So real estate, the whole economy will basically change if it really comes as a zero-cost to have you know, goods delivered, people delivered by a self-driving (car). So I think that is the only way you’d value Tesla as high as it is.

SIMON BROWN: And truthfully, Tesla is way ahead. Weimer’s doing their self-driving. Uber had a division, they’ve spun it out. But the difference here is that Tesla’s got, what, a couple of million vehicles on the road, and those are all kind of in a way beta testers for Tesla. So they are getting that mileage, they’re getting real-world testing, which is giving them a significant advantage over competitors.

VIV GOVENDER: Oh, yes. I do think that self-driving has the most grounded. Imagine if self-driving becomes viable, the first company that does it and proves that it’s safe – are you going to buy the second company? Why would you risk your life on (a company that is on) the way to getting there, when there’s something out there that actually works at the moment?

So, yes, if Tesla’s self-driving becomes a technology that they can market to the rest of the world, it’s not just going to be cars, there’ll be little scooters delivering your pizza to you.

There’ll be little self-driving vehicles weighing may be less than a hundred kilograms taking your groceries to your door. It becomes a very different world like I said. And I do think we will be seeing a first-mover advantage. That’s going to be quite large if Tesla gets it right.

SIMON BROWN: You said that to me before. There is no chance I’m getting into sort of second-place self-driving. I want the best self-driving. 

I’m not sure if you’ve… kept up with the Reddit, the Wall Street bets, sort of sub-Reddit on there. GameStop has been their most recent sort of target. Last Tuesday stock was trading at $20. Last night it closed at almost $150. It’s almost like this group of Redditors are kind of taking on Wall Street; they pick a stock and they go crazy with it. And so far the Redditors are seemingly winning.

VIV GOVENDER: Look, this is something that has been done before. If you look at the SoftBank situation a little while ago, if you look at the market fundamentals – not the stock fundamentals, but the market fundamentals – you often find ways to get an analysis of [something], especially if you go with some kind of size into the market, something that’s basically, for instance, heavily shorted, and you go with enough buyers in there, you are going to cause a short squeeze, a short squeeze that will force the underlying institutional buyer – shorter, rather –  to basically have to buy it back from you at a very, very high price. And you could force these out. I think you’ve seen that kind of stuff in the past as well. 

This is the first time I think that it’s really been done by a cognative number of smaller individual traders. You have seen larger institutional guys as I said,   Soft Bank and so on, mess around with this kind of stuff in the past. And so it’s almost like a case of being eaten by a shark, or being eaten by a bunch of piranhas. It’s still the same situation. 

But, that being said, this is a reasonably dangerous aspect as well, because you’ve got to get the pricing right. Eventually, you are not looking at the underlying fundamentals of the… stock…. If you look at the underlying fundamentals of the market, the supply and demand, the short stock availability and so forth, I do think that, like I said, it has been done in the past by large institutions. It’s just that we are seeing now some of the smaller guys out there, the retail traders, being able to coordinate via a mechanism like Reddit, and they’re also getting the same kind of results and the same kind of profits.

SIMON BROWN: And that happened last year with Hertz, with Kodak, but I think this was the more organised, perhaps. We’ll leave it there. Viv Govender, portfolio manager at Rand Swiss, I appreciate your early morning time, sir. 

Please consider contributing as little as R20 in appreciation of our quality independent financial journalism.



Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


No – Not overprices — Most American car companies are going to the wall in the next 5 years and Germans to follow when Gig Berlin opens !!!

Priced way beyond the Stratosphere.

Anything the Americans make will be overtaken by Japan, China and S. Korea.

Just look at what happened to the Gass Guzzlers in the USA in the 1970s to 1980s.

1. Self-drive (defined anywhere anytime nobody onboard) is a decade away. If that. Some highways, sure.

2. Self-drive has absolutely nothing to do with EV. I can as easily put the same tech on a diesel or petrol.

3. Tesla scored below 10th in an assessment of readiness for autonomous driving.

End of the day : only airlines beat the car sector when it comes to terrible return on capital invested.

The Reddit rent a mob are no doubt running pump and dump hype attempts for their bankster masters that weild the real clout in their manipulated and self-“regulated” markets. Fundamental analysis of the electric vehicle industry should include the China monopoly on essential mine supplies for these not at all green and very expensive = largely unaffordable means of basic transport. Restricted supply and enforced demand does not give a sense of sustainability, quite the opposite.
The truth would be refreshing but clearly not on the WEF agenda. One could and probably should become suspicious of their actual motives. Surely they are not this dimwitted.

Top story yesterday, dustbin today.

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: