Is a corporate excess profits tax on the cards?

Rather than increase taxes for citizens – who have reached their taxation ceiling – an unprecedented solution may be in order.
Unprecedented times require unprecedented solutions. Image: Shutterstock

As South Africa tumbles haphazardly into the second year of the epidemic, with uncertainty prevailing around when corruption will be curtailed, criminals jailed, the zombie state-owned entities (SOEs) culled, and the majority of citizens vaccinated, the only certainty is the steadily rising dam of debt.

Citizens are already being lumbered with more than their share of taxes, with value-added tax (Vat) and fuel taxes (which impact transport costs) being carried by even the very poor. They have reached their taxation ceiling (as indicated by the Laffer curve).

Moneyweb Insider INSIDERGOLD

Subscribe for full access to all our share and unit trust data tools, our award-winning articles, and support quality journalism in the process.

Choose an option:

R63 per month
R630 per year SAVE R126

You will be redirected to a checkout page.
To view all features and options, click here.

A monthly subscription is charged pro rata, based on the day of purchase. This is non-refundable and includes a R5 once-off sign-up fee.
A yearly subscription is refundable within 14 days of purchase and includes a 365-day membership.

Click here for more information.

Read: No matter the label, SA has little tolerance for tax hikes

Filling the Covid-19 fiscal hole

There are global calls for post Covid-19 fiscal policies to accelerate transformation, support the poor and struggling companies, and make those who have done well through the pandemic pay more.

But the emphasis seems to be on taxing so-called wealthy individuals. Gold mining, resource and technology companies have done very well in the last year.

A paper written by International Monetary Fund experts Ruud de Mooij, Ricardo Fenochietto, Shafik Hebous, Sébastien Leduc, and Carolina Osorio-Buitron, Tax Policy for Inclusive Growth after the Pandemic, raises valid policy considerations that are also applicable to South Africa, particularly this extract: “build their administrative capacity to better enforce existing taxes”.

Further crucial suggestions include “improve and simplify their Vat and excises, protect their income taxes better against avoidance and evasion, reduce discretionary tax incentives, enhance fiscal regimes for extractive industries, and better exploit taxes on property and pollution”.

Company tax rates (1985 to present)

Over the last 30 years, company tax rates have been slowly coming down. 

Between 1985 and 1991, the company tax rate was 50%. This was reduced to 48% for the next two years, and then 40% for 1993/94. In 1994/95 the rate was reduced to 35%, but a one-off transitional levy of 5% was introduced. In 1995 the tax rate was 35%, from 1996 to 2005 it was 30%. It slowly came down and is now sitting at 28%.

Corporates have not suffered any increases in tax rates in recent years.

And even the secondary tax on companies was passed on to individual shareholders when it was replaced with the dividend tax, effective April 2016.

Undistributed profits tax (prior to 1990)

The undistributed profits tax (UPT) was levied at 33.3% of a company’s distributable profits, less any dividend paid. There were exemptions for companies that were more than 50% held by foreign shareholders.

The UPT led to various tax avoidance stratagems, such as dividend-stripping tax schemes.

Secondary tax on companies (1993 to 2016)

The secondary tax on companies (STC), of 15% payable on dividends, was introduced for dividends paid after March 1993. The STC was borne by the company.

There were special rules for gold mining and insurance companies. The STC rate shot up to 25% in June 1994 and thereafter came down.

The STC rate was 10% when it was replaced with a tax on dividends, to be borne by the shareholder, which became effective in April 2016.

The STC also led to a proliferation of STC avoidance schemes, such as schemes that manufactured an STC credit.

One-off excess profits tax for companies

So why not have companies bear the additional Covid tax?

A one-off excess profits tax (EPT), say 5%, can be levied on the ‘excess profits’ of a company.

The excess profits could be calculated on the distributable reserves as at the end of the financial year, less capitalised interest, and less all unrealised profits such as the fair value adjustment to fixed assets (plant, machinery and equipment, land, and intellectual property), and less the dividends declared for the year. The distributable reserves will include dividends received. 

The rationale for using distributable reserves as a base would mean that companies that qualify for tax incentives (which will reduce the taxable income) could still be liable for the excess profits tax.

This tax should be limited to the larger companies, the threshold of which would have to be determined if the tax was introduced. It would also be easier to administer and apply as the audited figures would be readily available.

An advantage of such a tax is that it will be automatic, and the South African Revenue Service (Sars) will not have to increase its workforce. This is as opposed to a wealth tax on individuals, which is not only difficult to define, but for which Sars does not have the resources to administer.

Read: Rising debt, the fiscal deficit, and taxes

Keith Engel, CEO of the South African Institute of Tax Professionals, says that “this is an interesting academic concept”.

While stressing that he is not a fan of additional taxes, “an undistributed profits tax would be the least damaging amongst the alternatives and may be the most effective way to raise funds from those most able to pay”.

“Corporate funds otherwise left unused also seemingly do the least for economic growth.”

Engel cautions however that the tax shouldn’t force a company to liquidate assets.

No doubt National Treasury is mindful that in the current climate of rampant corruption, and the continuing cost of propping up zombie SOEs, any additional taxes imposed in next week’s budget will be viewed askance by taxpayers.

However, these are unprecedented times, which require unprecedented solutions.

Read:
Electricity tariffs to rise 15%
SAA pilots fuming over unpaid salaries

Listen: Wikus Furstenberg of Futuregrowth Asset Management discusses his expectations for Budget 2021 with Simon Brown; he believes an increase in personal income tax is unlikely.

Please consider contributing as little as R20 in appreciation of our quality independent financial journalism.

AUTHOR PROFILE

COMMENTS   5

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.

SIGN IN SIGN UP

Alrighty then, I can see companies hiding ‘excess profit’. And not paying x-mas bonuses or give employees annual increases. But perhaps it would be better to give excess profit as a bonus to employees just to spite SARS?

Any “excess profits” (never mind the definition of this ludicrous concept, I have no idea which companies in 2021 South Africa would be able to generate these) should be invested outside of SA. Every “larger company” in South Africa should start up a new company or two. On any continent except Africa, that is.

Only ones with “excess” profits seems to be Mines and of course the Cellphone companies. then you have the Corrupt Cadres which sits on the most excess profits of them all.

Although variations of an excess profit tax have been implemented in some other countries, the idea itself it totally against the entrepreneurial and capitalistic spirit.

In essence the argument is that the state (a proven corrupt, inefficient & ineffective allocator of resources) is entitled to punish those in the economy who are more successful by taxing them proportionally higher than other participants who are less successful. This while the successful participant had to take all the risks, but somehow are not entitled to the rewards if they achieve them.

The whole notion is utterly ridiculous… How about cutting expenses before increasing taxes..?

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR

TAX CALCULATOR  

How much do you earn per year?
How old are you?

Income:
Total tax:
Rebates:
Income after tax:

Income:
Total tax:
Rebates:
Income after tax:
Moneyweb is a financial, investment news provider and not a tax- or financial advice authority. Please contact Sars or a registered tax practitioner for any tax-related queries.
 
 

ECONOMIC DATA  

  CPIThe Consumer Price Index (CPI) measures monthly changes in prices for a range of consumer products Jan 2021 3.20%
  CPI ex OERThe Consumer Price Index excluding Owners’ Equivalent Rent (CPI ex OER) measures monthly changes in prices for a range of consumer products excluding Owners’ equivalent rent that measures changes in the cost of owner-occupied housing Jan 2021 3.40%
  RepoThe rate at which the Reserve Bank lends money to the country’s commercial banks and set by the Reserve Bank’s Monetary Policy Committee. Feb 2021 3.50%
  Prime lendingThe Prime Lending Rate is the rate of interest that commercial banks will charge their clients when issuing a loan (home loan or vehicle finance) Feb 2021 7.00%
USD/ZAR
GBP/ZAR
EUR/ZAR
AUD/ZAR
Yuan/ZAR
INSIDER SUBSCRIPTIONS APP VIDEOS RADIO / PODCASTS SHOP OFFERS WEBINARS NEWSLETTERS TRENDING PORTFOLIO TOOL CPD HUB

Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: