Sars should give crypto investors more carrot and less stick

Anecdotally, it seems the revenue service still views crypto assets as highly speculative intangible assets – but change is taking place in this industry.
If taxpayers have not declared crypto asset profits, it is advisable to follow the voluntary disclosure programme provided for by Sars. Image: Dan Kitwood, Getty Images Europe

It has been more than three years since the South African Revenue Service (Sars) issued a media statement on cryptocurrencies.

In that statement it stated that it will apply “normal income tax rules” to cryptocurrencies when assessing whether a gain is revenue or capital in nature and that crypto assets are not seen as currency for income tax purposes.

Moneyweb Insider INSIDERGOLD

Subscribe for full access to all our share and unit trust data tools, our award-winning articles, and support quality journalism in the process.

Choose an option:

R63 per month
R630 per year SAVE R126

You will be redirected to a checkout page.
To view all features and options, click here.

A monthly subscription is charged pro rata, based on the day of purchase. This is non-refundable and includes a R5 once-off sign-up fee.
A yearly subscription is refundable within 14 days of purchase and includes a 365-day membership.

Click here for more information.
Read:

Following this statement, further guidance has been scarce.

Clarity needed

Crypto traders, especially those who have no financial or tax background, often turn to fellow traders on social media platforms for advice (not an advisable option). Based on my interaction with cryptocurrency HODLers [‘hold on for dear lifers’] uncertainty remains, with many being surprised when I explain the so-called “normal rules”, which become pretty complicated as the crypto market continues to develop.

Media outlets, along with Sars Commissioner Edward Kieswetter, have been quick to state that Sars will crack down on non-compliant taxpayers who do not declare their crypto asset profits.

However, many of these taxpayers are not even aware that they are non-compliant. So why not provide more guidance to assist taxpayers in declaring their crypto asset profits?

The only guidance to date is the previously mentioned media statement along with 15 FAQs on cryptocurrencies hidden away on the Sars website here.

Anecdotally, it seems Sars still views crypto assets as highly speculative intangible assets, however, it should be noted that exponential change is taking place in this industry.

Cryptocurrencies have provided various initiatives and businesses that are shaping this alternative financial system. These initiatives include cryptocurrency arbitrage, investments into predefined cryptocurrency bundles, lending and borrowing through the use of decentralied finance (DeFi), and staking and mining rewards for solo or pooled staking and mining.

Incentive approach

At a minimum I would suggest that Sars together with National Treasury declares that gains (and losses) on crypto assets are deemed to be capital in nature if held for a period of, say, more than one year (similar to Section 9C of the Income Tax Act, which provides equity shares to be deemed to be capital in nature after three years).

In this way, Sars can assist taxpayers in obtaining certainty in their disclosures. It will also assist in bringing taxpayers to Sars, instead of Sars needing to try and find non-compliant taxpayers in a space it is ill-equipped to conquer.

With all tax collection methods, the cost of the collection must be weighed up against the actual amount that can be collected.

Providing this form of incentive will encourage taxpayers to disclose their positions and save Sars the cost of finding extremely expensive methods of obtaining this information from markets. Not to mention the number of devices that have come to my attention that shield this information from authorities.

Interpretation

For true transparency Sars should attempt to detail as much of the current crypto transactions it is aware of in an interpretation note – touching on aspects such as:

  • The interaction between crypto assets and Section 24J (interest);
  • Whether crypto to crypto conversions qualify as disposals (in my opinion it does);
  • The rebalancing of crypto bundle investments and whether these should fall within the ambit of a collective scheme of investments;
  • Staking rewards that could be argued as being interest; and
  • The tax implication of collateralised lending through DeFi.

In the meantime, if taxpayers have not declared crypto asset profits, it remains advisable to follow the voluntary disclosure programme provided for by Sars. Failing to disclose any relevant amounts could result in substantial penalties and/or harsh criminal sanctions.

Read: Cryptocurrency traders should prepare for stricter tax surveillance (Nov 2020)

As highlighted by Wiehann Olivier, Digital Asset Lead at Mazars, crypto assets were originally designed to facilitate peer-to-peer transactions across the internet. This meant there was no need for any intermediary or monetary regulations, which led people to believe that crypto assets should operate independently from any form of regulation.

However, they fail to realise that certain regulations are, in fact, imposed to protect consumers and economic stability.

Tertius Troost CA(SA) is tax manager at Mazars.

COMMENTS   12

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.

SIGN IN SIGN UP

Regrettably SARS are nothing but leeches – always looking for the soft spots to suck the taxpayer dry and then misappropriate funds

SARS only goes after law abiding citizens and not gangsters, politicians or people with mansions in Dubai and bank accounts full of Tax payer money in Pakistan or Dubai.

IF you heard Mbeki… yesterday

He said the ANC lied to its voters…. THERE IS NO GOOD STORY to TELL

“(similar to Section 9C of the Income Tax Act, which provides equity shares to be deemed to be capital in nature after three years).”

The period over which you hold an asset does not necessarily mean it is capital in nature. SARS still want you to prove that you did not hold this asset for a scheme of profit-making.

https://www.wylie.co.za/articles/investment-as-a-scheme-of-profit-making-v-investment-as-capital/

I have a problem with the legislation as it has a one size fits all approach. I should not be forced to hold onto a share for a certain period of time in order for it to be deemed capital in nature. The environment has changed and these thigs can chane their identity overnight. You act and then are forced to jump through rounds of questions to prove your intention my I should be given licence to invest how I see fit

The COUNTRY IS BROKE!! They need to tax, tax, tax! Remember when they mention more spending it is through increased taxes and taking more of your money to pilfer and spend.

No Crypto investors must treated like any other investment, from a tax point of view. Why should it be different ?

I’m also going to climb on my soapbox and point out the clear misinterpretation of what Bitcoin actually is, whether by the media or by companies looking to get rich quick from trading activity.
Exhibit number 1 – just look at the grandiose image depictions of these “coins”, being ornate and gold. This article being one of those.
Lets correct that image and change it to a bunch of numbers on a white background… There you go – a little less attractive? no?

Touché …. the irony.

Why should I, as a retail investor, be billed at my marginal, for any after tax money invested at a profit?

Heads, SARS win, tails, you lose.

Wish I could run a scheme like that, not paying for my losses and only have upside.

“Anecdotally, it seems the revenue service still views crypto assets as highly speculative intangible assets”. That’s being generous … and they are they are intangible, hugely speculative and cannot be described as an “asset”.

Obviously these things are speculative.

This 2021 tax year when everyone made profits they are going to cry its capital in nature.

Next year when all lost their money they are going to cry its income in nature.

I’ve been around this block many times.

When it come to tax people have no qualms to lie (even to themselves).

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR
BTC / USD

Podcasts

INSIDER SUBSCRIPTIONS APP VIDEOS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE SHOP OFFERS WEBINARS NEWSLETTERS TRENDING PORTFOLIO TOOL CPD HUB

Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: