Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

Only two provinces have above-average living conditions – report

New index finds they are the usual culprits: Gauteng and the Western Cape.

Gauteng and the Western Cape are the only provinces in South Africa with an above-average rating in terms of being able to cater for the social and environmental needs of the people who live there. 

These are the findings of the first subnational Social Progress Index in Africa by IQbusiness and international non-profit Social Progress Imperative, which focuses on SA’s nine provinces. The index measures a country’s performance on three dimensions: basic human needs, foundations of wellbeing, and opportunity. 

Within these it uses 12 components that ask questions such as whether people feel safe, if they drink water and keep themselves clean without falling ill, are their rights protected and are they free to make their own decisions, and do they have access to foundational education and adequate housing with basic utilities?

Beyond GDP

The index aims to move away from using just GDP or unemployment figures as a measure of economic progress, choosing instead to look at the quality of life of a country’s citizens and how wealth is distributed. 

“We know that stimulating GDP growth and reducing unemployment will scarcely be satisfying if the lived experience of all people who live in South Africa is not enhanced as a result of such growth,” Risenga Maluleke, statistician-general at Statistics South Africa, writes. 

“Experience has taught us that economic growth does not always translate into improvements in society and the quality of people’s lives.”

Through these metrics, Gauteng is ranked at number one, with an overall score of 68.01. The province scored highly on eight of the 12 components, with access to water and sanitation, inclusiveness and basic education at the top. The Western Cape is not far behind with a score of 66.7, mainly due to environmental quality, access to basic knowledge and nutritional and basic medical care. 

Provincial results by component

Source: 2019 South Africa SPI Index

But the ratings of the remaining seven provinces range from only 41.86 to 48.18.  

Other provinces

The closest contender to Gauteng and the Western Cape is Limpopo, with a rating of 48.18. Limpopo achieved the highest score for shelter, personal safety and personal rights – which refers to the freedom of religion and trust in the justice system. However, the province performed the worst on access to information and communications in a highly digitising world. 

Only about 4% of schools in Mpumalanga and Limpopo have access to the internet for teaching and learning purposes, while only 43.6% of households in Limpopo have access to at least one person who has access to the internet. 

“Communication plays an important role in the fundamental operation of a society, and its lack can have devastating effects,” the document states.

Limpopo and the Eastern Cape also had the lowest scores in terms of access to basic education.

The index uses adult literacy rates, matric pass rates, the percentage of children who are not at school due to disability and the percentage of people still schooling at 18 to 29 years of age to measure this component. 

Read: Is education the answer to SA’s stalling pace of innovation?

For instance, Gauteng (7.51%) and the Western Cape (5.04%) have the lowest percentage of 18- to 29-year-olds who are still in school, “suggesting that these provinces are more efficient than the others at graduating learners through the basic education system”.

In comparison, 24.36% of the 18 to 29-year-old population in Limpopo is still in school.

On the positive end, the index says the country has made great progress in increasing access to education for citizens.

Almost all adults between the ages of 16 and 84 are literate, compared with only 82% in the mid-1990s. 

Overall the country’s scores on access to advanced education were on the lower end, with only three provinces having ratings over 30%, “which is discouraging in the context of the role that advanced education must play for social and economic progress”.

Environmental quality

As the globe begins to create greater awareness on moving towards greener energy and the climate crisis, the lowest score on the index and the only single-digit outcome is Mpumalanga, with an 8.61 rating on this component. 

“It appears that the biggest issues facing Mpumalanga are around land degradation and littering … 71.84% and 56.29% of households reported [these] concerns respectively”. 

Read: Eskom financial woes cause worst pollution in 20 years

  • Another serious concern in Mpumalanga is related to air pollution.

A Greenpeace study recently found that the town of Kriel was the second-worst hotspot for sulphur dioxide emissions in the world, due to the coal power stations.

Targeted solutions 

IQbusiness chief executive Adam Craker stated that the SPI’s objective is to change the way the country measures its progress and does business. 

In deepening the analysis and transparency of national performance, beyond merely looking at economic indicators, the SPI gives a bird’s-eye view on the impact of government policies like the National Development Plan on people’s lives. 

“It allows us to measure the progress that will enable better decision-making, especially when determining priorities and budgets which can help advance the lives of South Africans,” said Craker. 

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.



To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

What is the water like in Gauteng?

Let’s hope the day doesn’t come where Gautengers say:

“We don’t know what the quality of our water is”

This reminds me of a story I read about an American politician. When he was told that half the students are below average he said, we have to improve this situation.

My thoughts as well – an earth shattering discovery to find the two richest provinces are above average and the rest below.

Clearly the American politician knows about asymmetric distributions and the difference between an ‘average’ and a ‘median’. Maybe one day your public schooling will catch up?

I mean, right in the headline of the article, we see only two being above average. The inverse is also possible. In a classroom situation, it is certainly desirable to have most of the students above the average. But keep on.

I did study statistics and know the difference between mean and median, but I also know that the mental capacity of people follow the bell curve and specially in case of large numbers the median and mean (average) is the same for all practical purpose. Of course in case of a small sample size of 9 the two can be totally different.

So you understand how this situation exists, but you still need to point out how it is somehow surprising. Okay. SA celebrating ignorance again.

This country only has one problem and that is TOO MANY PEOPLE. All these problems will easier to address if we had a smaller population including less illegal immigrants.

Indeed. The solution – effective birth control and border control – is never mentioned, but this is indeed the problem in SA. Too many people and an economy too small to support all of them. We don’t have 40% unemployment, we have 40% too many people.

Feel free to remove yourself and be part of the solution. But of course, you are talking about the mythical ‘other people’.

Too many people in SA who does not belong here.Actually too many in the world. Overpopulation.

Good article.
It also goes to show how low down the list the NHI is in most municipalities.
The People in these disfunctional municipalities just want help with decent living conditions – is that so hard to understand? If Julius Malema know this, it can’t be too difficult.
If the ANC want to keep the votes in the Municipalities they control, they have to forget about lofty NHI ideas and concentrate on delivering basic services like they have promised.

Load All 18 Comments
End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be cancelled at any time.



Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: