Foreign investors pile into SA bonds

Despite the jarring local news flow, the hunt for yield points investors to SA’s bond market.
Foreign investors continue to make allocations into SA's bonds despite political and economic uncertainty. But the outlook for local bonds remains precarious. Picture:Shutterstock

It’s not the world’s best-kept secret that SA is teetering off a fiscal cliff. 

The economy is barely growing, more credit rating downgrades might be on the cards, state-owned-enterprises have been engulfed in corruption scandals, and large investment decisions by companies have been put on hold pending the outcome of the ANC’s succession battle in December.

And yet foreign investors are not running for the exit. According to JSE data, foreigners bought a net R69.5 billion of South African bonds (mainly the key R186 ten-year government bond) in the year to end of September 2017.

Foreigners appetite for local bonds is in line with the inflows of R68.7 billion recorded in the year to the end of September 2016, which was significantly higher than the R8 billion in 2015 and R2.1 billion in 2014 over the same comparable period.

Although the wave of bad news continues apace in SA, the global search for an attractive yield by cash-flush foreigners has intensified, pointing them to the local bond market. 

“Foreigners take a different view on emerging markets risk than people living in emerging markets do. Foreigners are used to political turmoil, junk status downgrades, and uncertainty. It’s not news to them,” said Wayne McCurrie, senior portfolio manager at Ashburton Investments.

SA’s current ten-year bond yield at 8.6% (the interest rate that investors would receive on loans to the government) is more attractive than emerging market peers including Russia, India, and Indonesia, which are offering a yield of 7.5%, 6.7% and 6.5% respectively. This is the reason why foreign inflows have continued, coupled with SA’s bond market that is exceptionally liquid and sophisticated, allowing investors to get out quickly.

“No matter what the politics are in SA, our government is not about to renege on its debt. We are still a mile away from that and foreigners believe that they will get paid,” said McCurrie.

It’s important to note that the foreign inflows don’t necessarily mean that investors are comfortable with SA’s economic fundamentals and political uncertainty. “Those concerns are all there, but that is not the main driver when it comes to their investments. SA is attracting a lot of money but we remain vulnerable because the fundamentals are weak and not good,” said Kevin Lings, the chief economist at Stanlib.

Undervalued rand

SA bonds are receiving a fair share of inflows in the wake of an improved sentiment towards emerging markets.

Emerging markets inflows have been under pressure since 2015 as concerns mounted about China’s economic slowdown deepening, and Brazil and Russia sinking into a recession. Worsening these concerns was the possibility that the US Federal Reserve would hike interest rates, ending a sustained period of low interest rates.  However, China’s economy grew, Brazil and Russia came out of a recession and the US Fed now expects a gradual rise in interest rates. This re-energised investment flows into emerging markets.

Although SA’s prospects remain precarious, the rand has remained resilient, trading in a narrow range of R12.50/$ to R13.50/$ so far this year. At current levels (R13.63/$ at the time of writing), market watchers consider the rand to be undervalued, which has made local bonds attractive for foreigners. 

To underscore the undervalued rand, it would be useful to use The Economist’s Big Mac index. The index is centered on the theory of purchasing-power parity (PPP), which examines the divergence in the value of currencies between countries and their “correct” level. The index is a lighthearted guide to explain PPP and was never intended as a precise gauge of currency misalignment.

For example, the average price of a Big Mac burger in the US in July 2017 was $5.30. In SA, it was $2.26 at an exchange rate of R13.27 at the time or R31.52 for a burger. So the “raw” Big Mac index suggests that the rand was 57.3% undervalued against the US dollar using the PPP theory. The rand is the fourth most undervalued currency against the US dollar among 44 countries in the index, after Malaysia (62.2%), Egypt (66.9%) and Ukraine (68%). 

George Glynnos, the chief economist at ETM Analytics, expects the rand to retreat back to R12.50/$ to R13/$ as he doesn’t believe that the weakness in the local unit – by more than 7% so far this year – is the start of a big reversal for a rand that has remained remarkably resilient. McCurrie has put a fair value of R12 to the rand by end of year depending on commodity prices, which the local currency generally takes cues from. 

The Big Mac Index- July 2017. Sources: McDonald’s; Thomson Reuters; IMF; The Economist.

Bond buying opportunity?

So, are bonds now a buying opportunity given the attractive yield and undervalued rand?

In the short term (next three months) Stanlib’s Lings agrees as inflation has been kept in check and the search for yield is still strong. “Beyond that, we are flagging that there is too much uncertainty that we don’t fully appreciate relating to politics and credit ratings.”

In April, S&P Global Ratings cut SA’s foreign currency credit rating to sub-investment grade (or junk) while Fitch cut both foreign and local currency credit rating. Moody’s cut SA’s sovereign credit rating one notch above junk, with a negative outlook. A downgrade to junk of SA’s local currency credit by S&P and Moody’s in early December would be catastrophic, as the country could lose its spot in Citigroup’s World Government Bond Index.

South African government bonds became the first African government bonds to be included in the index in October 2012. If excluded from the index, many foreign asset managers with investment grade mandates would dump SA bonds.

This would put the rand at more risk, said Lings.

Another risk is the normalisation of US interests; if they rise rapidly SA bond yields would become less attractive. SA is dependant on inflows to prop up government spending, whereas other emerging markets like India and China offer foreign investors bond yields and economic growth.

“We can’t offer foreigners that [yields and economic growth]. If you are offering foreign investors only the search for yield trade, then that is the main basis on which you are attracting foreign investment. You become somewhat vulnerable. What happens if the search for yield is not as intense as it was?” said Lings.

Another risk to bond yields is the ANC leadership elective conference outcome in December. Said Ashburton Investments’ McCurrie: “If there is a truly positive political outcome, bonds would rally by 50 basis points and maybe even a full percent.”

Right now, it’s anybody’s guess what a positive political outcome might be.

AUTHOR PROFILE

COMMENTS   10

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.

SUBSCRIBE NOW SIGN IN

apparently these inflows are VERY short term – to December to be exact. after that – watch this space!

Robert, I think you use the correct word ‘’apparently’’ in your statement, without quoting your source…
I am a recently retired FX Corporate Treasury dealer and operated in this market for a lifetime.
I still meet lots of my ex colleagues and friends in the Bank’s Corporate Treasury market every month.
We always discus the USD/ZAR market, money market, capital market and the capital flows and the time value of money…
Every single dealer agrees that this market re-acted fantastic under the strain of a lot of ‘’stork’’ capital they left with the run up to ‘’junk status’’.
They also assured me that there are still a unbelievable demand for our bonds etc and that the ‘’carry trade’’ market is still very active as the ‘’yield’’ remains king!
I don’t believe that anything will change, soon!

>>
They also assured me that there are still a unbelievable demand for our bonds etc and that THE ‘’CARRY TRADE’’ MARKET IS STILL VERY ACTIVE as the ‘’yield’’ remains king!

I DON’T BELIEVE THAT ANYTHING WILL CHANGE, SOON!
<<

+100

the business is debt, not debt default

An analysis of your comments over the past few years suggest you are
– deeply unhappy with moving to Australia
– can not make any friends there
– will use any opportunity to run South Africa down
– did not make it in your new country of choice
-any good news about South Africa is rejected

Your many warnings of the collapse of your country of birth have not been correct -stop that now please, you are only embarrassing yourself.

You remind me of the divorced man being invited to family Christmas dinner and as soon as everyone is happy and enjoying themselves – you urinate on the Christmas tree

I am here to help my erstwhile countrymen. if you can’t see that then please move on!

Is there not a Moneyweb or equivalent in Australia for robertinsydney?

It is not all doom and gloom for South Africa as some expats believe.

There is a lot of Economic potential in South Africa and also a lot very good human capital.

Please do not look in the rear view mirror all the time, move on.

Most are running for the exits. I have articles that show Money has POURED out of this country since 2012 AND it is getting larger and larger on the amounts leaving. To quote YOUR paper 03 Oct 2017 “outflows from South Africa’s stock exchange have already reached 90.5 BILLION this year, on track to equal last year’s RECORD R 125.8 BILLION.” So what’s it going to be Money web? Playing both sides of the coin OR the left hand doesn’t know w hat the right hand is doing? Me thinks the latter.

This is good news for SA as I see it – albeit short lived.

I, for one, am happy for SA

For as many decades as I can remember, we have been told that the Rand is undervalued, according to the “big mac” index and other selected indicators.

That may or may not be true, but I have never known the Rand to strengthen on that. Just because it may be considered to be undervalued, does not mean that it will revert to any norm or “estimated” correct value.

Clearly these valuation analyses are wrong.

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR
BTC / USD

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Moneyweb newsletters

Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.
INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP VIDEOS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE SHOP OFFERS WEBINARS NEWSLETTERS TRENDING

Follow us: