You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

170 billion reasons why the state would want to capture the Sarb

The South African Reserve Bank is a treasure house for spendthrift ministers and will likely remain a target.
The government may be trying to capture the Reserve Bank in order to access its assets and forex reserves, which would help solve some of its budgetary constraints. Picture: Bloomberg

Former Reserve Bank employee and now senior economist at Efficient Group, Dawie Roodt, says there are 170 billion good reasons why the state would want to get its hands on the assets of the Reserve Bank.

He says last year’s failed attempt by the public protector to alter the mandate of the South African Reserve Bank may be a prelude of what’s to come.

Assets worth R170 billion are reflected on the Reserve Bank’s balance sheet as belonging to the state – most of them unavailable for state spending. The state will have to borrow R224 billion in the current fiscal year to finance its budget, and will be looking for any cash it can lay its hands on. 

Of the R170 billion Reserve Bank assets belonging to the state, R70 billion was accumulated when Trevor Manuel was finance minister and tax revenues exceeded budget projections. The economy was powering ahead and foreign inflows meant too much money was in circulation, with the danger that inflation would ratchet out of control. An amount roughly equivalent to R70 billion was transferred from the state to the Reserve Bank to take some of this money out of circulation, but with the agreement that this money could not be used for state spending in the future. It was a smart idea by Treasury, which seems to have anticipated that a future administration would make a claim on this money. These funds now sit on the Reserve Bank balance sheet as a liability to the state.

The Reserve Bank also holds about R100 billion in forex that belongs to Treasury, but this too may only be used for foreign currency transactions, and is not available for domestic state spending.

Roodt says the state would love to get its hands on this money to help solve some of its budgetary constraints: “R170 billion would solve a lot of problems, like SAA, Eskom and other state-owned entities, which have huge debt obligations falling due. I suspect this was the reason the public protector last year brought out a report recommending a change in the Reserve Bank’s mandate. Though this was rejected by the High Court, I believe we may see further attempts to weaken the Reserve Bank.”

Last year public protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane attempted to have the Constitution amended to change the Reserve Bank’s mandate, which is to protect the value of the currency. The Constitution also requires the Reserve Bank to perform its functions “independently and without fear, favour or prejudice”, but in consultation with the cabinet.

Mkhwebane also ordered Absa to repay a R1.12 billion Reserve Bank bailout stemming from its acquisition of Bankorp in the 1980s. Absa and the Reserve Bank are opposing this, and the matter is currently before the court. The attempt to alter the bank’s mandate was rejected by the North Gauteng High Court, but Roodt believes that this was not the final attempt to capture the Reserve Bank.

“This is not unique to SA,” he says. “Governments everywhere try to capture funds wherever they can find them. [With the state] having allowed state-owned companies to be run into the ground, and with nowhere else to look for extra money, it seems inevitable that the Reserve Bank would come under attack.” 

There were also reports that the Gupta’s attempted to gain influence at the Reserve Bank by trying to employ retired executives with knowledge of the inner workings of the bank, which is required to oversee banking legislation, including money laundering and foreign exchange transactions.

Apart from the R170 billion in Treasury deposits and forex reserves belonging to the state at the Reserve Bank, there is quite a bit more that would solve some of the Treasury’s budgetary shortfalls. The Reserve Bank is also custodian of the country’s reserves, comprising mostly gold and other forex reserves. These reserves, translated back into rands, increase whenever the local currency weakens.

The value of these reserves now stands at about R240 billion, due to the weakness in the rand in previous years.

That means that roughly R410 billion is potentially available for state spending if theReserve Bank can somehow be captured, says Roodt. For that to happen, a more agreeable team of governors at the Reserve Bank would have to be put in place, and the agreements between the Reserve Bank and Treasury preventing this money being used for state spending would have to be renegotiated. If that could be achieved, the state could potentially have access to R410 billion to feed SAA, Eskom and other state-owned companies

This kind of short-term solution would have longer term negative consequences: should the state gain access to these funds to plug holes in the budget, this would massively increase liquidity in the economy, and would unleash inflationary pressures. Assuming the Reserve Bank was still interested in protecting the value of the rand, it would have to drain some of this liquidity by issuing Reserve Bank debentures at a high cost — eventually for the account of the taxpayer. If the Reserve Bank chose not to drain liquidity, inflation would be the result.

“How does this end? It always ends in one of two ways,” says Roodt. “Either government cuts its spending, or it inflates away its debt. In most cases, it is the latter.”

Please consider contributing as little as R20 in appreciation of our quality independent financial journalism.



Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


If SARB gets captured it will be the final straw – no matter who is in power. The fact that the Guptas tried and failed is only down to the fact it ( SARB) is a privately owned entity and not a state owned one.

While it is the politicians with a mandate from the poorer part of society that pushes for nationalization of the already nationalized Reserve Bank, it is also the poor who will be the victims of such an action. Any populist solution to slow growth and a declining economy will lead to devaluation of the currency. This erosion of the purchasing power of social grants will rob the poor of basic necessities, while enriching the wealthy part of society who own assets that rise along with inflation. This is the reason why all socialists are eventually driven to nationalize all private property. The fact that socialist policies eventually serve to widen the wage gap and leads to increased inequality, puts enormous pressure on the socialist politician to redistribute the wealth of property owners.

The property owners did nothing to deserve this. They are not to blame for the increase in their wealth. Their house, farm or quantity of shares is still of the same size. The size of the property did not increase, it was the value of the property that increased along with the decline in the value of the currency. It is the populist policies of government that caused the increase in the relative wealth of the owners of assets. In order to hide this unavoidable consequence of socialist policies from their supporters, they revert to nationalization of private property.

The farther of modern economic policy predicted end described the exact situation that we are facing in South Africa at the moment wih the following statement.

“By a continuing process of inflation, governments can confiscate, secretly and unobserved, an important part of the wealth of their citizens. By this method they not only confiscate, but they confiscate arbitrarily; and, while the process impoverishes many, it actually enriches some. The sight of this arbitrary rearrangement of riches strikes not only at security, but at confidence in the equity of the existing distribution of wealth.” – JM Keynes

That’s why no one saves in South Africa, just get yourself into debt and you can count on the government to inflate your woes away.

This is the type of thing where distributed ledgers/escrow/smart contracts could really shine. No amount of bribery, threats or even mass delusion on social media can change a piece of cryptographic code.

R400 billion is a lot of money. however the current fiscal deficit is R200 bn. Thats overspending for only one year. Given the current tax revenue and government expenditure the R400 bn will last 2 years. After that, SA will be out of reserves with yet another deficit to finance.

I wish you are wrong!!!, but … … …

In 1986 Andy Lamont in Pacaltsdorp, George told me that the ANC is eyeing the reserves held at all the Municipalities.

Those reserves are long gone now, actually, as we all know, most Municipalities are in the red.

Can anybody think of another reserve to be drained?, or is the Reserve Bank the last big one to raid?

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: