Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

Ayo investment passed on by Matjila – suspended PIC exec

Two PIC executives suspended with immediate effect amid inquiry into governance.

The inquiry into governance at the Public Investment Corporation (PIC) was briefly disrupted on Tuesday during the testimony of the executive head of listed investments at the corporation, Fidelis Madavo. This came as an announcement was made by the PIC confirming the suspension of Madavo and assistant portfolio manager Victor Seanie.

In a statement released by the PIC, it said that a report on a preliminary investigation was submitted to the board on January 21 and “clearly reflects a blatant flouting of governance and approval processes of the PIC”.

“Employees of the PIC have also been implicated in these irregularities. It is for this reason that the board has resolved to suspend Mr Fidelis Madavo and Mr Victor Seanie with immediate effect.”

The news sent shudders through the hall of the inquiry with the commission confirming that it too had only just learnt of the suspensions. 

Read: PIC inquiry: Corruption or sheer incompetence?

The suspensions are inconsistent with the PIC’s head of Corporate Affairs, Deon Botha’s tone in June last year. He reiterated: “Just because of the media noise regarding the Ayo deal, the board saw it fit to satisfy itself that the Ayo deal was conducted following best practice. The investment committee has since confirmed that nothing untoward happened when we invested in Ayo.”

The transaction he was alluding to is the controversial R4.29 billion injection into Ayo Technology Solutions ahead of its listing in 2017, despite warning signals surrounding the company’s valuation. Consequently, the hasty investment has so far cost the PIC over R2.7 billion as Ayo’s share price tumbled from R45 to R23. The misconduct queries were also exacerbated by confirmation last year that close acquaintances to Iqbal Survé had acquired shares in Ayo since its IPO. 

Back at the inquiry, Madavo confirmed that the Ayo Technologies investment was passed to his team by the PIC’s CEO, Dan Matjila as one to consider. This fuels earlier allegations that Matjila had in the past used his position to lobby funding for specific deals.

It now seems to be clear that much of the inquiry’s queries will scrutinise the procedural undertakings at the asset manager with a particular focus on the Ayo transaction. Further questioning on the Ayo valuation has revealed the PIC’s investment processes have some weaknesses.

“In the case of Ayo, I think there were a number of assumptions there. Remember they were going to invest in a British Telecom stake and there were also assumptions on the various platforms that they had,” said Madavo.

When asked whether there were any internal debates within the PIC on Ayo’s valuation, he admitted , “I was out of the country, I only saw these reports after I came back so whether there was (a debate) or maybe there was a debate. I was not part of it.”

The revelation raises questions on the PIC’s internal procedures. If a R4.29 billion valuation could be approved on the basis of assumptions and without consultation with the in-house head of listed investments, what else was approved?

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.



To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

Well, well, no surprises here. The country is riven with corruption and ineptitude. All coming out now. What an awful picture for inward investment! Iqbal Surve swanning around Davos may have to face some very embarrassing questions.

And where are the many thousands, if not millions, of civil servants today? Not even a whiff of a protest march anywhere?

Gosh, but they remain a bunch of uninformed people – masses of sheep blissfully unaware of anything around them other than the 15th of the month when they can buy more TVs, cars, latest fashion outfits, etc. Most probably never heard of the PIC…..

Load All 4 Comments
End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Or choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be suspended at any time.



Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: