Proudly sponsored by

DNG Energy’s legal challenge to stop Karpowership IPP deal dismissed

Also ordered to pay legal costs.
The judgment ends a legal saga that has prevented successful bidders from concluding financing arrangements with banks on their projects. Image: Waldo Swiegers/Bloomberg

South Africa’s energy department said a court challenge to its so-called emergency power programme will likely delay the provision of 2 000 megawatts of electricity to the national grid by seven months.

The lawsuit, filed by a losing bidder, was dismissed by a High Court on Sunday and DNG Energy, the company behind it, was ordered to pay legal costs.

The legal proceedings forced the Department of Mineral Resources & Energy to extend the deadline for winning bidders to complete their financial arrangements by two months to the end of March, with the additional electricity expected to come online a year later. When the contracts were first awarded, the target was August of this year.

“It is expected that these projects will be operational and ready to deliver much needed generation capacity to the national grid starting 12 months from financial close,” it said in a statement.

While the judgment ends a legal saga that had prevented Turkey’s Karpowership, which won the right to supply 1,220 megawatts, and other successful bidders including Scatec ASA, Acwa Power Co. and Electricite de France SA from concluding their contracts, other hurdles remain. Agreements have to be signed with national power utility, Eskom, and Karpowership needs to win environmental approval for its three ship-based, gas-fired power plants.

SA’s environment department rejects floating gas plant
Karpowership plan hit by new corruption allegations

DNG had alleged that corruption involving government officials led to Karpowership winning the business. The government countered that DNG’s bids didn’t meet its requirements and rejected accusations of wrongdoing.

“The demonstrable reason for DNG’s unsuccessful bids was because it failed to meet a myriad” of qualification criteria, Judge Joseph Raulinga said in his ruling. The company also submitted additional documents without getting the correct permission from the court, he said.

DNG had demanded that its bids replace those of Karpowership.

“I believed in the merits of our case and we will study the judgment,” DNG Chief Executive Officer Aldworth Mbalati said in an interview. “If we believe there are merits for an appeal we will appeal.”

The delays could prolong intermittent power outages that South Africans have been experiencing for more than a decade because Eskom can’t meet demand. Those outages hit a record last year.

Read: Consumers should not have to pay for Eskom’s Medupi, Kusile mess – Asac

While Karpowership would burn gas to supply power, some of the other bids included solar power projects in addition to diesel and gas.

Karpowership has been “convincingly vindicated by the ruling,” the company said in a response to a query. “We are one very significant step closer” to commercial closing and the implementation of the company’s three projects.

© 2022 Bloomberg L.P.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


As rate payers and Corporates are the ones keeping Eskom financed, I believe they should be the ones to dictate where alternate energy supply comes from. In my opinion it would be from eco friendly solar and wind – natural resources this country has in abundance. A far cleaner, fairer, job creating and more economical source than ( politically engineered) polluting powerships from Turkey!

I see it slightly differently. I say those that pay for power should be able to source it from a number of options, not from a monopoly.

Turkeys don’t vote for Christmas they say. Mantashe says if we want to have any electricity by Christmas we should vote for Turkeys.

End of comments.




Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: