Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

University fees cannot fall

Instead, government-guaranteed bank loans could fund university fees, according to the recommendations of the Heher Commission of Inquiry. This is in stark contrast to President Jacob Zuma’s unconfirmed and populist policy on free education.

All undergraduate and postgraduate student fees should be funded through a model in which commercial banks would issue government-guaranteed loans to students that are payable upon their graduation.

This funding model – referred to as the “income contingent loan system” or ICL – is part of the findings of a long-overdue report by the commission of inquiry into free higher education and training headed by retired judge Jonathan Heher, who was assisted by advocate Gregory Ally and Leah Thabisile Khumalo.

The inquiry examined the feasibility of making higher education and training fees free in SA after widespread protests at universities across SA that initially began in 2015.

Students, academics and industry players have called for free tertiary education that would be funded through the diversion of public resources from other government sectors and the introduction of additional tax, especially on top income earners. However, the Heher Commission has called for a financial aid system that is “more efficient, more sustainable, more user-friendly, and more equitable.”

The 752-page report, released by President Jacob Zuma on Monday, found that the ICL system would be for students attending private and public universities and colleges, regardless of their background. 

Should students fail to reach the required income threshold after graduating in order to repay the loan, then government bares the secondary liability of the loan. 

“The commission recommends that commercial banks issue government guaranteed loans to the students that are payable by the student upon graduation and attainment of a specific income threshold,” the report said. 

The Davis Tax Committee, headed by Judge Denis Davis, has proposed a similar model. The committee, which released reports on various aspects of tax administration on Monday, proposed a system of government-backed student loans to decrease or eliminate financial exclusion from higher education. This would see government collaborate with financial institutions to administer loans to students. 

Unlike conventional loans, which could fuel a debt trap among millions of students, a repayment method proportional to future earnings guarantees (the ICL system) is widely viewed as fair given that some students will end up paying more than they have loaned, thus subsidising those whose jobs are not remunerated well enough. This model is already adopted in Australia, New Zealand and England. 

The collection and recovery of the government-guaranteed loans will be undertaken by the South African Revenue Service.

“The state can guarantee the loan or, better still, purchase the loan, so that the student becomes a debtor in its books… No student is obliged to repay a loan unless and until his or her income reaches a specified level. If the loan is not repaid within a specified number of years, the balance can be written off.”

If the government opposes the commission’s ICL system, it should then consider the model of Ikusasa Student Financial Aid Programme, a funding model launched in 2017 with a selection of universities. ISFAP adopts a hybrid model involving public grants, bank loans, and donations to provide support financial support to students, particularly the so-called “missing middle”, who cannot afford the costs of tertiary education and don’t qualify for loans. ISFAP has attracted financial support from private institutions, which have donated over R138 million.

TVET colleges 

The Herher Commission has recommended that the National Student Financial Aid Scheme (Nsfas), which currently funds university students, be replaced by the ICL system. Instead, Nsfas would be retained for the provision of funding at institutions including Technical Vocational Education and Training, known as TVET colleges, as this sector is facing severe financial pressure, which “impacts on the quality and innovation of the sector, and on the student experience.”

The commission also recommends that government increase its expenditure on higher education and training to at least 1% of GDP (in line with comparable economies), consider the introduction of a university fee capping mechanism, application and registration fees to be scrapped across the board, and that government adopt an affordable plan to develop more student accommodation.

The findings contradict Zuma’s unconfirmed and populist plan of pushing a free-higher education policy for students coming from families earning a combined annual income of not more than R350 000. To implement this, the Mail & Guardian has suggested that Zuma is considering a range of budget cuts that could include slashing social grants and curtailing the roll out of social housing for the most vulnerable citizens. The Presidency has denied this.

Zuma’s free education policy would cost R40 billion to an already constrained fiscus and put the National Treasury’s budgeting process under significant strain. If Zuma pushes his policy, it would undermine the Treasury’s role in keeping a lid on government spending, wasteful expenditure and finding sustainable ways to grow the economy.

Zuma has been sitting on the Heher report since receiving it on August 30 and has defied calls to release it from university institutions, opposition parties, and even the axed Minister of Higher Education Blade Nzimande. The delays in releasing the report have frustrated students and management of university institutions. At the time, Zuma said he was studying the report’s contents and consulting the relevant ministers, excluding Nzimande, who was fired by Zuma in his cabinet reshuffle in October.

On Monday, Zuma said he had decided to release the Herher Commission report prior to the conclusion of government’s work in processing it so that the public could have an opportunity to study the report. He said the inter-ministerial committee, led by Minister in the Presidency Jeff Radebe, and the presidential fiscal committee, led by Minister of Finance Malusi Gigaba, were still processing the report.

“I will make a pronouncement on the report once the ministers have concluded their work,” said Zuma.



To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

How funny is it that he sat on the report for 2 months, then fired the minister who you would think he was consulting in that time? Haha Zuma is a legend!

your autocorrect has written ‘leg’ – i am sure you meant ‘bell’

We as a nation, need to approach this university fees issue with sober minds. Pre year 2000/2002 there about, all the Zimbabweans received assistance for their tertiary education through the government, and i mean all, without favour/screening etc etc. The money advanced to the students was 50%grant and 50% loan and this made all kids from the poorest of families access to high quality varsity education. I think those of you who have zim skills within your employee will testify to this. Therefore as a country we need to do a fact finding exercise and see how the zim government successfully implemented this policy of education assistance and also countries like Cuba. Cuban scientists, doctors, etc are all over the globe doing their thing. We cannot juss push our kids aside and say there is no money. i for one know that there is plenty of money to fund our kids. we could trim the cabinet by 3/4, and manage that cost centre better, civil servant are being paid ridiculous amounts of money for sitting on their behinds, how do you explain a situation where one gets is it 70% of your car allowance being paid by govt yet kids are going without fees? We could prioritize things that matter the most to us which is our children education, imagine how much money was wasted when we hosted the 2010 WC yet we have kids at this day and age in the EC who are learning in pole and dagga classrooms? Im with the students on this, lets get our priorities right.

All the stolen money could fund free education for years.

These clowns have only themselves to blame……again.

No money for education because the thieves (led by JZ) do not want to stop thieving.

I am glad in that amongst other things; the report propose two pertinent issues:

1) Scrapping of registrations fees (some universities demand close to R10K upfront as registration fee)
2) Student Accom

Often, these are a barrier of entry to poor students (been there, got the Tshirt)

Lastly; I still believe the poor can be funded 100%. The rich must pay

Banks should be careful about this one . government is notorious for not paying its bills . also when granting loans banks should get potential candidates tested by their own ajudicaters because affirmative action and fraud in schools gives grades that are often undeserved just to fill quotas

Not necessarily…

Government should actually be worried of giving too much power to white capitalist Banks

The only thing that can fall with the ANC is wages.
The only thing that can rise with the ANC is the sovereign risk (besides the cost of borrowings, corruption and nepotism).

Clueless will be applying his mind shortly (for a very long period of course)…the most dangerous is when Clueless consult his clan after his sabbatical period (when he applied his mind). Track record so far has been disastrous….

The recommendations of the 3 commissioners? are vintage Africa stuff. Politically correct but totally out of touch with logic,reason and economic reality.What a joke. Nice job if you get it though.

Load All 11 Comments
End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Or choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be suspended at any time.



Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: