Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

It’s election year, so expect a wild ride

Land expropriation and elections are the wild cards in scenario planning.

If volatility is your thing, 2019 could be a great year. All the elements for a roller coaster ride are in place: an election in May, a trade war between the great powers, and the unresolved land expropriation issue.

It’s going to be bumpy, but not necessarily bad.

Bianca Botes, corporate treasury manager at Peregrine Treasury Solutions, paints a number of different scenarios for the year. They range from the good to the ugly: at its best, state-owned companies are turned into cash machines, land expropriation is handled sensibly, the global trade war resolves, SA’s credit rating improves and the rand strengthens to R10 to the US dollar.

That’s unlikely, certainly in 2019. Also unlikely is the worst-case scenario where SA goes the way of Venezuela with hyper-inflation; state-owned companies go bankrupt; land redistribution is mishandled, resulting in mass defaults on mortgage loans; capital flees the country; and business and consumer confidence is destroyed. Should that happen, expect the rand to go to R25 to the US dollar, says Botes.

A more likely outcome for the year lies somewhere between these two extremes, with the rand trading between R14 and R16 to the US dollar. That requires no serious shocks to the system, state-owned companies continue to muddle along in a generally poor state of financial health, the economy shows no real spark and outside geopolitical events remain volatile. In other words, pretty much like last year.

A slightly better outlook is also a definite possibility: finance minister Tito Mboweni gets a steady grip on state-owned companies and ratings agencies improve the sovereign rating by a notch, there is a gentle up-tick in the economy, interest rate changes are carefully paced, and land redistribution is handled sensibly and equitably. In this instance, the rand’s range would be between R11.50/$ and R13/$.

Even the middle-of-the-road scenarios leave plenty room for volatility, with the rand capable of swinging 40% in either direction.

That should be great news for traders, less so for long-term investors with an aversion to volatility.

Much will depend on the outcome of the May general election and whether President Cyril Ramaphosa gets the mandate he needs to implement policy changes for stronger growth. Without growth, the economy will continue to shed jobs and cast a pall over his presidency.

Bear in mind the rand has a propensity to wild swings. In 2017 it gained 23% against the dollar, and this played havoc with stock prices. Political events, including the firing of Pravin Gordhan as finance minister and the inauguration of Ramaphosa as president, played a major part in this move. The JSE All Share Index is exactly where it was in March 2016. In 2018, the rand veered between R11.50 and R15.30 to the dollar, a swing of about 33%.

Political events, here and abroad, will overshadow the investment outlook for local and international equity markets in 2019. Maarten Ackerman, chief economist at Citadel, says cracks are now starting to appear in the 10-year bull market – one of the longest bull cycles since World War II.

Global economies performed well in 2018, backed by solid corporate earnings, yet markets decoupled from these fundamentals. “While the long-term bull market remains intact for now, the pullback in global markets does signal weakness,” says Ackerman. “The question is a matter of when, rather than if, the trend will end.”

Geopolitical events are causing uncertainty, from the likelihood of a messy Brexit to the spread of ‘yellow vest’ street protests in France and elsewhere, and the trade war between China and the US.

Using a basket of 10 economic indicators, Ackerman says he sees a low possibility of a US recession in 2019, but there is a stronger possibility of recession in 2020.

“The market has already priced in the weaker economy and, coming from a low base in 2018, we expect equities to rebound over the course of 2019, with upside potential still on offer to investors, although in a more volatile environment,” he says. “Rather, a tougher year is more likely to materialise in 2020 when the US will need to negotiate higher interest rates and growth disappointments in an election year. A recession could even be a possibility then, with a dismal US equity market to match.”

SA has scope for economic recovery, but much depends on the outcome of the election. The structural defects of the economy remain intact: from an excessive debt burden and floundering power supplier to almost insurmountable unemployment.

It’s going to be a rocky year for investors with an outside chance of a bear market. A defensive strategy is advisable through the use of hedge funds of funds, protected equity and defensive stocks.

“At this stage we view global equities as offering better prospects than South African counters, especially Europe and Japan,” says Citadel.

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.



To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

Sounds more and more like gambling and less like investing every day. Personally, I would have been better off had I cashed in and put everything in a good old 12 month fixed deposit this time last year. Defensive strategies sounds good, but does it have more potential than fixed deposits?

Fixed investments worked very well for me for past 3 years. 8%+ risk.No costs and a tax break. No fin advisors. JSE started 2018 at about 60 and ended at about 52.

Bianca Botes – these are such ‘’nothing’’ comments/predictions/scenarios that you are referring to.
Even the guy selling the newspaper will tell you that the bad news will be the ZAR at 25 against the USD and good news at 10.
I think Treasury outsourcing companies like Peregrine Treasury Solutions should realize that they are in competition with big Authorised Dealers with very competent Treasury dealers. Authorised Dealers all operate as principles with foreign exchange licences, whereas Outsourcing companies must try to ‘’add a service’’ (advice?) as they operate as third parties without any foreign exchange licenses. They hardy see the daily FX flows and rely on ‘’information’’ that are sourced through various third party channels.

Election year. If you are white and don’t enjoy being told by political parties that you are not welcome in South Africa, I suggest you switch off the news until May.

Add to this that use the time saved filling in forms for emigration. I have one slow eye on the SA debt, currently just over 50% of GDP but climbing. Stagnant growth and no sign of any proper fixed investment spend in national assets that will show a return and improve growth and/or enable payback of debt. Spend is on salaries, grants, vanity projects and just plain stolen or wasted. If you add SOE and municipal debt to the national debt, I’m guessing it could be over 60% and that is begging for a bailout territory and ZAR collapse.

Tell me it ain’t so, please.

Maarten Ackerman, under a heading ‘’Kenners kies hulle beste beleggings vir 2019’’ on the Netwerk 24 website, also failed to mention any asset classes and shares. Both FNB and PSG gave a very good run-down of asset classes and shares they would like to have in a portfolio.
Which begs the question – doesn’t Citadel understand the question as alluded to in the headline? Haven’t we had enough ‘’political paraphrasing ‘’ already before the elections?

Unemployment figures in the USA topped at 25% during the worst part of the Great Depression. Under the ANC government we have an unemployment rate of 30% and rising. It is a symptom of a shrinking economy when cash outperforms the share market. Cash has been outperforming shares for the last 4 years. Market leaders like Coronation, Aspen, BTI, AB Inbev and MTN are more than 50% off their highs. This combination of signs tell us that the South African economy is in a depression that it worse than the 1930 Great Depression.

Do you think this will shape the opinion of voters during this election year? Socialism, populism, criminality and incompetence are taking its toll on the local economy.

Thanks Sensei, regarding SA unemployment figures (versus the 1930’s depression)….never thought of it that way!! 😉

It just shows one what level of hardship South Africans in general endures, and we think it’s “normal” 😉

Will hardship (like a recession) sway the majority’s vote?? DOUBT IT. Large parts of Africa has been in economic hardship for decades (worse than a recession in the western world), but African people continue to allow poor political leadership in their countries. Level of education is problem number-1.

Load All 8 Comments
End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Or choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be suspended at any time.



Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: