Joburg to defend drastic school rates increase in court

Decision flies in the face of Bill of Rights, says AfriForum.
Even the state as owner of school properties will be affected, putting pressure on funds earmarked for new schools or the improvement of infrastructure. Image: Shutterstock

The City of Joburg has given notice that it will defend a decision that led to a drastic increase in property rates for schools, universities and colleges, in court.

This follows an urgent application by civil rights group AfriForum to have the decision to remove the rates category ‘education’ from the city’s rates policy reviewed and set aside.

Moneyweb earlier reported that public schools and tertiary education institutions will in future be assessed as ‘public service property’ and pay about six times more than before, while independent schools, universities and colleges will be assessed as businesses, paying about 10 times more.

AfriForum hopes the application will be heard in the High Court in Pretoria before the end of July, when the first increase may show up on bills.

Unbudgeted

According to an affidavit by Morné Mostert, head of municipal affairs at AfriForum, public schools and tertiary institutions face an increase of 529%, while independent schools, universities and colleges face an increase of 686% if they qualify for a 25% rebate (the rebate is not available for public schools). Without it, the increase will be considerably more.

This means that a public school with a valuation of R70 million that has been paying about R12 000 per month for rates, will in future be expected to pay about R75 000 per month. An independent school with the same valuation will see its R12 000 monthly bill increase to R96 000 even after applying the 25% rebate it may qualify for.

Mostert says these institutions will not be able to pay these increases. Their budgets for the year were finalised some time ago, and on the assumption that the increases in municipal rates and taxes would be reasonable.

They will have to increase tuition fees to a level where parents won’t be able to afford them, he says.

Even where the state as owner of school property is responsible for the payment of rates, it will place an unfair burden on the relevant department and money earmarked for new schools or the improvement of infrastructure will have to be used to pay the municipal bill.

Mostert says organs of state are supposed to promote the rights contained in the Bill of Rights, which is part of the Constitution, but this Joburg council decision flies in the face of it. The best interest of the child is not paramount, as the Constitution provides should be.

Read:
More and more municipalities move to tax game farms as businesses
Sandton City disputes claims that it owes City of Joburg R158m

According to Mostert, the City of Joburg created the impression during the public participation on the rates policy, that it would retain the ‘education’ category and educational institutions would only see a 2% increase in rates. This was later changed without consulting stakeholders again.

Therefore, most institutions are totally unaware of the rates shock awaiting them.

The process the city followed is therefore flawed and on that basis alone the decision should be set aside, according to Mostert.

Mostert further states that the director-general of the Department of Basic Education has indicated that his department was equally not consulted about the decision. That means the city has failed to follow legal prescripts to consult other organs of state about the decision and the possible impact it may have.

He says there is no reason why the special category had to be removed and even if it did so, the council could have mitigated the impact with a meaningful rebate.

Teachers’ union SAOU is keeping an eye on the issue, according to its CEO Chris Klopper. He said public schools are on government property and as such the Department of Education is liable for the rates. In many cases schools are however paying for rates out of school fees because the department fails to make the payments.

Klopper says the union will ensure that the department takes responsibility and pays these bills in future.

Listen to Fifi Peters’s interview with AfriForum’s Morné Mostert on school rate hikes (or read the transcript here):

COMMENTS   4

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.

SUBSCRIBE NOW SIGN IN

The City of Joburg should rather concentrate on collecting from the residents that don’t pay and stop writing off billions in unpaid for utilities year after year after year.

How the mighty ( ANC ideals of free education for all) have fallen! A shocking indictment of the reality of a failed state. Education and Birth Control are possibly the only two things that could get us out of the mess the ANC have landed us in….both of which will never happen as long as they make education expensive and out of reach for the majority and award grants to those that keep on having children, unwed and unsupported by everyone apart from the taxpayer.
The divided and corrupt ANC are now governing in emergency mode….time for change

Is it not the DA in charge via coalition in Johannesburg?

Thieves, that is all they are, nothing more, nothing less. If all else fails increase taxes/levies/rates, no accountability to anyone.If they were efficient and did not steal/ squander/ destroy there would be more than enough cash to go around.

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR
BTC / USD

Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Moneyweb newsletters

Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.
INSIDER SUBSCRIPTION APP VIDEOS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE SHOP OFFERS WEBINARS NEWSLETTERS TRENDING

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: