Registered users can save articles to their personal articles list. Login here or sign up here

Nersa rejects Tshwane’s fixed charges and proposed power tariffs

Regulator will also ensure that overcharged consumers are refunded.

Energy regulator Nersa last week rejected the City of Tshwane’s controversial electricity tariff application for 2019/20 and decided to allow it to simply add 13.07% to the previous financial year’s tariffs for the current financial year.

That is exactly what pressure group AfriForum asked Nersa to do during the round of public hearings in July – on the steps of the court after it stopped Tshwane’s unlawful implementation of tariffs that did not have Nersa’s approval.

Nersa also indicated that it would set up a tribunal to deal with Tshwane’s non-compliance with the Electricity Regulation Act. While the tribunal would have the power to fine the city for every day the non-compliance continues, from discussions during Nersa’s electricity sub-committee meeting, it seems the focus will be on ensuring that Tshwane refunds customers who have been overcharged.

The tariffs that Tshwane proposed and unlawfully implemented from July 1 included a basic charge of R56 for residential customers and R250 for those paying agricultural tariffs. These charges had been included in the city’s approved budget at R200 and R610 respectively, but were hastily reduced following public pressure.

After reaching a settlement with AfriForum the city reverted to last year’s tariffs and the monthly bills for July were finalised on that basis. 

Prepaid customers, however, paid the R56 basic charge in July – and although the city stopped this, it continued to levy prepaid customers on increased and unapproved tariffs per unit consumed.

Some resellers even proceeded to charge households in sectional title complexes a R200 basic charge, since the city seemingly overlooked this when it reduced the basic charge for households buying prepaid electricity directly from the municipality.

Legal conundrum

It is still unclear from what date the Nersa-approved tariffs will apply or how the city will be able to get around the provisions of the Municipal Finance Management Act (MFMA), which requires public participation and approval of tariffs before the beginning of the financial year on July 1.

The MFMA specifically stipulates that municipalities may only adjust tariffs on July 1 and not during the year.

Municipal governance expert advocate Werner Zybrands says the law will not allow retrospective tariff adjustments if consumers are being prejudiced, which is what an increase would boil down to.

He also says that should the city continue with the implementation of the Nersa-approved tariffs now, any group of consumers that wants to challenge this on the basis of non-compliance with the MFMA, and can show substantial prejudice, will most probably succeed in court.

A senior source in National Treasury confirmed that implementation of the tariffs now would be in contravention of the MFMA.

However, Mare-Lize Fourie, Tshwane MMC for finance and herself an expert on the MFMA, sees no problem.

She says there is a precedent for the implementation of new tariffs after the start of the financial year and that the increase of 13.07% Nersa has given Tshwane is in line with what was communicated to the public during the budget process.

Post-paid customers may have to cough up

If the implementation goes ahead and the approved tariffs are applied retrospectively from July 1, Tshwane’s post-paid customers who were billed at the previous years’ tariffs will have to pay the amount by which they were undercharged in July.

This would also apply to end users in residential complexes who buy their electricity from resellers who are members of the Electricity Resellers Association of South Africa (Erasa). Erasa members stuck to the tariffs that applied in the previous financial year in an effort to stay on the right side of the law. 

Its members have not yet billed post-paid customers for July and are waiting to get detail from the City of Tshwane about the implementation of the Nersa-approved tariffs before doing so.

Get access to Moneyweb's financial intelligence and support quality journalism for only
R63/month or R630/year.
Sign up here, cancel at any time.


To comment, you must be registered and logged in.


Don't have an account?
Sign up for FREE

Another epic fail, brought to you by the same incompetent DA administration that also pushed through an 18% increase for the Pretoria City’s fat cats, and caused the riots 2 weeks ago. Apparently no different to the ANC when it comes to bungling and the inability to organize.

What amuses me the most, is that politicians that cannot even count to 10 are in control of service deliveries. Where does the money come from to pay for these kind of increases? Allover South Africa their only solution is to increase rates, with nothing of better service delivery.

Like everyone else in SA the DA is also just a bunch of (You know what I mean)

I guess we deserve the gutter.

We need a new opposition party. DA about to fold if you ask me.

Post paid is an admistrative pain in the neck, for both the administration and the public… let all electricity be prepaid… Finish & Klaar…

Will solve a lot of problems like overbilling … and cheaper when you go off the grid with solar.

Now is the hour …. to tackle Cape Town DA.
(Water and power “meter” tax.)

Yay, only 13% increase.

That just about 3 times the inflation rate

Just the fairy tale inflation rate, the real one is more like 13%.

The sad reality is that these cities have to balance their budgets and it was traditionally done with cross subsidisation from electricity and water tariffs. In simple terms; someone has to pay for the free stuff the poor (and refugees) get – houses, water, electricity etc etc. The city buys Eskom electricity for R0,80 say and sells it to the “middle class” for 100% mark up. Not just DA Pta, only the percentages differ a little.

Big business are hard to strongarm as their products become unaffordable or they move.

Snag is that it is not sustainable.

Excellent work, Afriforum! What an unbelievably mess-up (putting it politely) by SA’s so-called official opposition. And what happened to James Selfe’s investigation into 18% salary increases to the DA metro employees? We deserve to know!
And where’s the DA leader while all this is happening AND wards in by-elections are being lost to the ANC? Seemingly saving souls in some pilgrimage in Australia – what a poor performance by the DA! Learnt well from the ANC.

Go-go DA! Stuff it up! ANC has shown us that the worse you govern, the longer you govern….

Load All 13 Comments
End of comments.


Insider GOLD
ONLY R63pm

Moneyweb's premium subscription is a membership service which will give you access to a number of tools to take charge of your investments.
Choose a yearly subscription at R630pa - SAVE R126

Get instant access to all our tools and content. Monthly subscription can be cancelled at any time.



Follow us: