You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

NEW SENS search and JSE share prices

More about the app

New trade idea for SA is debt relief for climate goals

Backers of the proposal hope creditors can be persuaded that climate change is a global problem so urgent that it’s worth forgiving debts in developing nations.
Image: Waldo Swiegers/Bloomberg

Politicians and academics are turning their attention to a new trade pitch for South Africa: debt relief in exchange for progress toward global climate goals.

The debt-for-climate concept, which was floated by International Monetary Fund Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva in April, has been picked up by South African Deputy Finance Minister David Masondo and the South African Communist Party, which is part of the country’s ruling coalition. The IMF plans to raise the idea at the COP26 climate conference in Glasgow in November.

Moneyweb Insider INSIDERGOLD

Subscribe for full access to all our share and unit trust data tools, our award-winning articles, and support quality journalism in the process.

Choose an option:

R63 per month
R630 per year SAVE R126

You will be redirected to a checkout page.
To view all features and options, click here.

A monthly subscription is charged pro rata, based on the day of purchase. This is non-refundable and includes a R5 once-off sign-up fee.
A yearly subscription is refundable within 14 days of purchase and includes a 365-day membership.

Click here for more information.

Backers of the proposal hope creditors can be persuaded that climate change is a global problem so urgent that it’s worth forgiving debts in developing nations to help them pay for costly transitions to cleaner energy. While such initiatives have been tried before, they’ve never been realised on the scale that South Africa would be seeking.

The initiative would have multiple benefits for Africa’s biggest emitter of greenhouse gases. South Africa’s finances have been battered by its debt-ridden electricity company, Eskom, which has required repeated bailouts and cash injections. The government is also seeking financing to switch Eskom from mostly coal-fired power to cleaner renewable energy.

The price tag for that transition would be astronomical though, costing as much as R400 billion ($28 billion), according to Masondo, the deputy finance minister. Under his proposal, R146 billion to R213 billion of sovereign debt would need to be forgiven or deferred, allowing the government to give Eskom an equity injection, help it secure green financing and close polluting power plants.

Private creditors

“This is not a debt restructuring and private creditors or bondholders would not need to take a haircut,” Masondo told Bloomberg on Wednesday. “It should be a voluntary act by current or new holders of debt, or climate-focused financiers, to support the South Africa energy transition.”

South Africa’s Treasury said Masondo’s comments are his personal views and not government policy. The South African Communist Party’s central committee said in an August 29 statement that it welcomed the idea of swapping debt for green financing, which would enable Eskom to simultaneously shift toward renewable energy and tackle its debt burden.

Mark Swilling, deputy chairman of the state-owned Development Bank of Southern Africa and an advocate of the debt-for-climate swap, sees climate funds run by institutions such as the World Bank as potential backers. Major asset managers that are trying to burnish their green credentials could also contribute, he said.

“We are going to have to spend a load of money to buy ourselves out of trouble and there are people who recognize that,” said Swilling, who is also co-director of Stellenbosch University’s Centre for Complex Systems in Transition. “Everyone wants this to happen, they need a model.”

Debt transactions related to environmental targets have been done before, albeit on smaller scales. In 1992, Poland agreed to environmental concessions in exchange for forgiveness of a $3 billion debt it owed to the Paris Club of creditors. In 2017, $30 million of debt that Seychelles owed to the Paris Club and South African creditors was scrapped after it agreed to undertake conservation measures.

Transition blueprint

Pakistan is also innovating in climate-related finance, and expects to issue a so-called nature-performance bond of up $1 billion this year, according to Malik Amin Aslam, a climate-change adviser to Prime Minister Imran Khan. Swilling said that while other countries including Indonesia — a heavy coal user — could be candidates for a debt write-off, South Africa has the advantage of being smaller and having a more sophisticated financial system.

Any agreement should ideally be at government level to avert fears that Eskom might default, Swilling cautioned.

“You don’t want the creditors to smell blood,” he said.

A South African swap would be targeted primarily at governments focused on climate change, “but, with the right structure, could also attract investment from corporates working to meet net-zero or offset commitments,” Masondo said. New creditors could purchase small portions of foreign-owned debt and then forgive it in return for the South African government meeting emissions-reduction targets, he said.

“High levels of indebtedness can hold up what is urgently needed — an acceleration of the energy transition,” Masondo said. A deal in South Africa would create “a blueprint for other transitioning middle-income, coal-dependent economies.”

© 2021 Bloomberg


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


Lets look at some numbers before we just consider what the consequences of the above proposal will mean.

National debt R2.78Tril + Municipal Debt R2.78Tril + Consumer Debt R2Tril + State Owned Enterprise Debt R1.5Tril = total debt R8.5Tril
That should be taken on a single loan over 99years with the repayment done as 1% unclaimable VAT.

The minute they start with debt forgiveness, ordinary folks will behave in the same way. Why should the behave any differently if we are all equal?

For Pitys Sake !!!
If you trade in your Gas Guzzling V8 for an Electric Car , will the bank
“forgive” your debt as you are saving the Planet ??
These Loonies come from a different Planet !!
No Doubt this is only proposed for Triple BEE whatever etc Debtors :
Animal Farm was Fiction , RSA Isn,t !

I can’t believe that the Economic powers-that-be would fall for this. All they have to do is take one look at the corruption in our organs of state to realise that this is not true sovereign debt they would be forgiving, but theft of billions of dollars of funds that were never actually used to benefit the people of South Africa.

Let me lay it our for them: The ANC Government has rolled out a “dirty” coal energy Electricity program fraught with Corruption and mismanagement. stealing Billion borrowed through Sovereign debt mechanisms. Now they are asking to scrap that debt in exchange for fixing the dirty systems they defrauded and intentionally implemented in the first place.

The ANC is asking the world to forgive the debt they pilfered and embezzled.

If the ANC manages to con international investors into forgiving our debt due to climate change I will actually be seriously impressed. Forget the morality of it – it’s a genius move!.. The ANC criminal organisation is going international – stealing from international taxpayers too.

Sounds like extortion to me. Forgive our debt or we’ll continue polluting? Its like the car thief – car guard symbiosis.

Can the Eskom Pension Fund and the PIC get the ball rolling to show how this great idea works and how popular it is with their members?

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: