SA sees selling coal plants and visa reform boosting GDP

Reforms could lift the average economic growth rate by 2 to 3 percentage points and create more than 1m jobs, says National Treasury.
National Treasury describes SA's current economic trajectory as unsustainable and can only be turned around through 'deliberate and concrete action'. Picture: Moneyweb

South Africa’s National Treasury outlined its vision to bolster economic growth and tackle a 29% unemployment rate, proposing a range of reforms including cutting red tape for businesses and easing visa rules to boost tourism.

The reforms could lift the average economic growth rate by 2 to 3 percentage points and create more than one million jobs over a decade, the Treasury said in a policy paper released on Tuesday.

While proposals such as easing visa rules and releasing broadband spectrum could be low-hanging fruit and have also been suggested by the Reserve Bank and International Monetary Fund, others, such as selling off power plants owned by state utility Eskom and introducing new rules that will let households and companies sell excess electricity they produce back to the national grid, may be more difficult to push through.

Read: Eskom could sell some coal-powered plants to raise R450bn

The policy paper is an attempt to circumvent obstacles to structural reform in both the cabinet and the ruling African National Congress and is likely to trigger an angry reaction from within the government and parts of the party, according to Frans Cronje, chief executive officer of the Johannesburg-based South African Institute of Race Relations.

It “is likely to be welcomed in analyst and investor circles but not sufficiently to change investor sentiment, and will rather be read as further evidence of the contradictions and confusions that continue to bedevil government policy in South Africa,” he said.

Weak growth has exacerbated social pressures in Africa’s most-advanced economy and failure to create jobs and reduce income inequality could spark unrest. The economy contracted an annualised 3.2% in the first quarter, the most in a decade, as power shortages curbed output.

The Reserve Bank projects growth of 0.6% for the year. That’s well short of the more than 5% rate the government says is needed to halve the unemployment rate.

The Treasury described the current economic trajectory as unsustainable and said it could only be turned around through “deliberate and concrete action.” The country also needs “a stable macroeconomic policy framework underpinned by a flexible exchange rate, inflation targeting, and credible and sustainable fiscal policy,” the Treasury said.

Read: Evidence that shows Ramaphosa has a jobless crisis in SA

Release spectrum to aid SA’s economy, Sarb says 

These are some of the other proposals in the paper:

  • Allocate broadband spectrum to private companies through an auction, with a small set-aside for a government-controlled network. Competition should be allowed in Telkom’s infrastructure.
  • Visa regulations should be amended to ensure a better balance between security concerns and the growth of tourism. The tightening of visa regulations is out of step with a global move and while other countries are typically making it easier for tourists to travel, South Africa risks falling behind, the Treasury said.
  • Grant third-party access to the rail network to promote private-sector participation.
  • All infrastructure projects of strategic importance should be developed in coordination with government, the private sector and state-owned companies to alleviate pressure on the balance sheets of these firms.
  • Water demand will exceed supply by 2030, so the country needs a strategy for investment in water-resource development, bulk-water supply, and waste-water management and should apply lessons from the renewable energy independent power producers program.
  • Small businesses should receive full or partial exemptions from certain regulations, including labor laws, to lower the startup costs and reduce the regulatory burden.
  • Conditions for banking licenses should be made less onerous and banking regulations should be more flexible to new developments, such as the growth of mobile money
  • Fuel-price regulation should be reviewed, particularly in terms of spot price benchmarks and where regulation has supported incumbents such as Sasol.

The paper is out for public comment until September 15. What may further complicate finance minister Tito Mboweni’s efforts garner support for the 77-page document as policy is that it doesn’t mention three key ANC’s decisions: expropriation of land without compensation, nationalising the Reserve Bank and investigating the use of prescribed assets of pension funds to boost inclusive growth.

While Treasury’s proposals are similar to those stated in previous development plans, it is unclear whether they will be supported or lead to coordinated policy action because they have not been issued by the government, Nema Ramkhelawan-Bhana an economist at FirstRand Bank’s Rand Merchant Bank, said in a note.

“The proposals are a further demonstration of our country’s ability to conceptualise practical solutions but, at the same time, an expression of its failure to execute on seemingly well-thought-out plans,” she said

© 2019 Bloomberg L.P.


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.


Well Treasury seems to have the required understanding. Now can they please implement asap!

Someone is at least trying to do something. Well done Mr. Mboweni.

You will find many of the scarce skills in SA. Unfortunately from the community currently being discriminated against.

This headline sems incorrect; it is Treasury saying this, not Ramaphosa, not Gordhan and not the ANC government. These worthies are saying pretty much the opposite; no sales, split up Eskom, maybe a half hearted attempt at easing Zuma / Gigaba visa idiocy.

Mboweni’s suggestions are excellent. Problem is that the ANC crooks with their hands in the cookie jar will vehemently oppose most of them. Oh, if they could only be swiftly put into orange overalls, we could see a rise back to 5% growth, much more employment and less crime. Here’s hoping for a miracle! This country is too beautiful to just go down the tubes.

Instead of having a plan to ease visa restrictions how about easing visa restrictions? Stroke of a pen.

1 million jobs in 10 years sounds great, but the number of unemployed is growing by 300 000 a year, so even if they succeed the number of unemployed will be 2 million more in 10 years time.
“Conditions for banking licenses should be made less onerous” Why, are the cadres running out of the money they stole from VBS Bank and need fresh supply?

All logical steps, other than perhaps the banking license regulations. I’m not sure shareholders/depositors in African Bank or VBS would agree with that. I also don’t think competition in banking is needed nor that hard to get, look at Capitec, nothing really special about them but they have done very very well.

On the other points, all logical but how many logical white papers or reform programmes have we seen over the past 2 decades and how many have actually been executed to a high level, almost none I suspect.

There are good people in the ANC here and there but overall they are pretty useless.

What will boost the economy to new heights in this country is eradicating BEE and implementing free trade for all, regardless of colour creed or social standing. People can’t do business in this country due to restrictive BEE policies so thousands are leaving monthly and tens of thousands are left jobless, catch a wake up! BEE is causing this depressed economy but they are too proud to admit it!

A few voices in Treasury is not “SA”, and these ideas will be stillborn and pilloried by the venal and evil ANC.

End of comments.





Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: