South Africa’s tax policies viewed through the prism of Covid-19

Is the country keeping abreast of reforms as it grapples with the economic fallout of the pandemic?
The OECD says raising taxes on labour and consumption won't go down well politically; governments will have to find new ways to raise taxes. Image: Getty Images

South Africa is attempting to paddle in a big pond. But with the degree of corruption and lack of capacity to bring its tax criminals to book – not to mention the fiscal hole created by government policies that have hampered trade and had a knock-on impact on excise duties and other taxes collected – how can it discuss tax policy reform in isolation?

It cannot, and the comparative analysis of tax policy reforms in some 40 countries, including South Africa, released by the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) thus makes for interesting reading.

Titled Tax Policy Reforms 2020: OECD and Selected Partner Economies, it can be viewed here.

Covid-19 landed with a bang, creating a large crater in the fiscal profiles of many countries, necessitating immediate policy responses such as income support to households, and various initiatives to enable companies to survive the liquidity crunch.

The jury is still out as to how effective this has been in South Africa, or the exact degree of corruption involved. The public is unlikely to ever see a list of companies that requested support or the amount of support they received.

Sometimes, respecting the confidentiality of taxpayer information protects the criminals.

The OECD has identified several notable issues:

  • The pandemic has exacerbated existing inequalities.
  • Raising taxes on labour and consumption in the future will not go down well politically; governments will have to find new avenues for raising taxes.
  • No international agreement has been reached on the taxation of digital businesses.

With regards to the latter – South Africa was one of the first countries in the world to make it mandatory for offshore companies carrying on digital businesses in South Africa to register for value-added tax (Vat), and a few years later advertising was added. In other words, Vat should now be payable on the advertising paid to offshore companies.

But if an offshore company does not register for Vat, what will the South African Revenue Service (Sars) do?

Advertising no doubt creates quite a large hole in the fiscus, as it is tax-deductible when paid offshore, even though the income will not be taxed in South Africa.

In my view, South Africa has a parallel reality and is struggling with its own demons.

The pandemic has highlighted serious issues that are ultimately impacting state coffers in SA:

  • Covid-19 has intensified the loss of advertising to offshore tech giants such as Google. In South Africa, the first sign was the closure of many magazine titles. Australia is the first country attempting to get Facebook and Google to pay for content created by traditional media companies. France is following.
  • Attempting to work at home or within small business premises during a power outage when you have no back-up power is not conducive to productivity – and is further aggravated by the loss of cell phone coverage caused by the theft of batteries from cell phone towers.
  • South Africa’s open borders – as evidenced by the flow of illicit tobacco products.
  • The glaring inability of the government to make rational business decisions.
  • The frightening reality of state capture, and the toxic roots that have spread far and wide.
  • The criminal mentality.
  • When Covid-19 came to town, South Africa’s pantry was bare. The kitty had been cleaned out.

Pascal Saint-Amans, director of the OECD Centre for Tax Policy and Administration, stressed the uncertain future and said that tax policies will have to be adaptable.

The OECD divided the tax policy responses to Covid-19 into four phases:

  • Liquidity and income support;
  • Liquidity, solvency and income support;
  • Fiscal stimulus; and
  • Raising revenue. 

Solvency and income support

Several countries ceased audit and debt recoveries for all but high-risk cases. Others are trying to ease the tax burden on companies, particularly small ones. Some are taking the opportunity to clamp down on companies that are registered in “non-cooperative tax jurisdictions”. Such jurisdictions would, for example, not have signed exchange of information agreements and would therefore not furnish information on beneficial owners.

Fiscal stimulus

Some countries have provided preferential tax treatment to stimulate health-related spending and investment.

An interesting paper written by Busi Sibeko and Gilad Isaacs for the Institute for Economic Justice, termed – A Fiscal Stimulus for South Africa – argues that “a fiscal stimulus in the South African context should aim to boost both growth and employment in a sustainable and equitable manner”.

Raising revenue

Public finances will have to be restored, and countries will be looking at ways to tax the digital economy (this has been a seven-year project), and new sources of tax revenues.

South Africa will have to find ways of raising new revenue, but will also have to cut wastage. It must rein in its zombie, mismanaged, and corrupt state-owned entities (SOEs). How many billions have the SOEs squandered over the last year?

Sibeko and Isaacs reason that “there is considerable room to increase domestic resource mobilisation in South Africa”.

“Increasing tax revenue would entail raising income tax rates on high-income earners, taxing wealth and income derived from wealth more effectively, reducing tax deductions for the rich, more effectively taxing large corporations, clamping down on tax avoidance and illicit financial flows, and rebuilding capacity within Sars,” they say.

“Other domestic resources include mobilising quasi-state funds, such as those accumulated in the Government Employees Pension Fund, and better utilising Development Finance Institutes.

“Lastly, there is room to improve efficiency, capacity and/or performance of government resources. Addressing quality of spend requires capacity building which also requires additional resources.”

Greener, more resilient economy

The OECD’s Saint-Amans also suggests that when governments shift from crisis management to structural reforms, they should “seize the opportunity to build a greener, more inclusive and more resilient economy … rather than simply returning to business as usual”.

South Africa, unfortunately, has to first rid itself of its criminal element, and stem corruption, before it is too late.

It is unlikely that any tax policy, no matter how well researched and brainstormed, will make an iota of difference at this stage.

AUTHOR PROFILE

Get full access to Moneyweb's financial insights and support quality journalism.

Only R63 per month or R630 per year. You can cancel at any time.

COMMENTS   6

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.

SIGN IN SIGN UP

The term “tax criminals” is used in the article. Apparently the ANC regime lacks the “capacity” to bring them to book. Maybe capacity is not the correct word. I would recommend “capability” instead. I don’t think the regime is understaffed. Maybe understaffed with honest competent individuals.

Be that what it may, just what constitutes a tax criminal? Is it an individual who through either negligence or intent fails to timeously render his or her hard earned wealth to the criminal ANC regime who are destined to plunder it wholesale (or a large portion thereof) without suffering any legal consequences whatsoever?

Or is a tax criminal one that engages in theft or misappropriation of tax monies, extorted by force or threat of force, ostensibly for the proverbial greater good? At all levels of government, there is no lack of capacity in this regard.

Or is a tax criminal simply one that rides the government gravy train, consuming wealth but producing nothing in return for society?

Many years ago I was walking along the beach at Gordon’s bay when I chanced upon a dog (a black labby, friendly as they are) covered in ticks. There must have been hundreds and hundreds. Large grey engorged bloated parasites. The dog appeared well fed and had a collar. I remember thinking any more and the poor mutt’s gonna be sucked dry and die.

Yes, every parasite needs a host for survival. The ANC is no different. The only difference is the South African host has run dry. They have run out of other peoples money and the other people with money and wealth generating capability are leaving and taking their money with them or have long gone.

ANC have truly destroyed the beloved country.

What may make an iota of a difference is the introduction of a absolute transparency law for all things UIF, tax and any form of government or SOE tender.

Otherwise it will be more of the same where the ANC’s prisoners, NSFAS students and dead get UIF benefits and cadres continuing to loot like their is no tomorrow, pandemic or not.

The solution to tax collection is actually very simple.

Step:
1) Scrap all taxes
2) Blockchain bank accounts
3) Build the taxation of 9% into the Blockchain
4) all transaction to be taxed except for the person’s internal accounts

Because taxation transactions would take place in realtime, the Goverment would receive the money right away

1 Tax % for all products would be on step closer in creating a free market economy where millions of transactions take place every day.

I think you may have prompted a new name for some (most? all?) SOEs … SOZs for State Owned Zombies

Destroy the economy through stupid decisions and follow it up with a market cratering lockdown that throws millions into hunger and starvation ….and then ….tax the rich, take their pensions and have EWC for good measure.

And then what? That money won’t last 5 minutes, the rich who can will leave, and you are in a hole with no way out.

Wonderful stuff. How about, get the money stolen in state capture back, jail corrupt people, get the Guptas, cut the bloat in government and SOE’s , disband Eskom and give it to people like engineers who can actually run it, and scrap bee, the fountainhead of all corruption.

By the way, a huge turnaround could be achieved in SOE’s and municipalities simply by installing competent managers instead of cadres. Try hiring CA’s as CFO’s and engineers in water and electricity.

Build an economy, and then tax it.

But this doesn’t address the wrongs of apartheid and Jan van Riebeek.

So we’ll just collapse things, steal and loot, and become a failed state any time soon.

The average voter, as represented by the South African government, has zero moral authority to levy taxes. The average citizen abuses the power of his vote to extort financial support from the small minority who pay taxes. The ANC government has lost all credibility and legitimacy. We have a failed state that supports a handful of well-connected looters and criminals. The organs of the state, the SOEs, government departments and municipalities are optimally structured for looting the common resource and to steal from everyone else.

The ANC officials are a loose affiliation of bandits and highwaymen parading as legitimate public representatives. They represent only their own narrow interests to the detriment of society. This disaster and disgrace is the legacy of the ANC “elders” who, out of criminal negligence, ignorance and self-interest, implemented a socialist/communist system of government. They planted and watered the seeds for the implosion of South Africa.

No amount of taxation can prevent us from hitting the fiscal cliff. This criminal government will inevitably fall back on the stealth tax, the most destructive form of taxation, namely money printing, in an attempt to cover the shortfall in government expenditure.

The ANC elders have empowered the average ANC supporter to turn his economic reality into a manifestation of his mindset. We can describe that mindset in financial terms as the worst situation possible, namely a hyperinflationary collapse of the currency. The ANC – A better life for all.

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR

Podcasts

NEWSLETTERS WEB APP SHOP PORTFOLIO TOOL TRENDING CPD HUB

Follow us:

Search Articles:Advanced Search
Click a Company: