You are currently viewing our desktop site, do you want to download our app instead?
Moneyweb Android App Moneyweb iOS App Moneyweb Mobile Web App

NEW SENS search and JSE share prices

More about the app

Testing times for subsidiaries caught up in SAA maelstrom

Mango ratcheting up costs due to delays in returning leased aircraft, while SAA Technical staff are ‘very close’ to withholding their much-needed labour.
SAA Technical’s problems could result in even deeper crises for the local and international airlines that depend on it for technical service. Image: Supplied

An international private equity group has been waiting nine months for Mango – the broke, low-cost subsidiary of South African Airways (SAA) – to return two Boeing 737-800 aircraft after the leases expired in July last year.

Read: Why did PwC not identify corruption at SAA? 

Moneyweb Insider INSIDERGOLD

Subscribe for full access to all our share and unit trust data tools, our award-winning articles, and support quality journalism in the process.

Choose an option:

R63 per month
R630 per year SAVE R126

You will be redirected to a checkout page.
To view all features and options, click here.

A monthly subscription is charged pro rata, based on the day of purchase. This is non-refundable and includes a R5 once-off sign-up fee.
A yearly subscription is refundable within 14 days of purchase and includes a 365-day membership.

Click here for more information.

The planes are stuck at SAA Technical (SAAT), another broke subsidiary of SAA, which is undertaking the work necessary to ensure compliance with return conditions.

Such conditions are agreed upon at the outset, and airlines need to make provision for funds to meet them at the end of the lease. Over and above technical requirements, the conditions often include specifications regarding seat configuration and painting of aircraft before they are returned.

According to Carlyle Aviation Partners, Mango is incurring penalties that amount to 50% of the lease amount.

Mango, on the other hand, says the extent of the penalties must still be discussed with the lessor.

One of the planes was eventually returned a week ago, and SAAT says the other will be ready by the end of April and that Carlyle could deliver it to its new lessee, FlySafair.

Mango unable to pay

According to a senior manager at Carlyle, who asked not to be named, Mango has been unable to pay SAAT for the work that had to be done.

Last year Carlyle made weekly payments to SAAT as the work progressed, but SAAT eventually fell behind schedule and Carlyle stopped its payments.

SAAT confirmed that Carlyle had been making payments, but blames Covid-19 disruptions – which made it difficult to get the necessary spares and consumables – for the delay.

According to Carlyle it even paid for work on one of the aircraft engines that was done at Lufthansa Technic in Germany.

On return to South Africa however, the engine got stuck in customs because Mango failed to pay the import duty.

SAAT confirms that payments were made by Carlyle in this regard. It confirms that the engine arrived back at its workshop on December 15 last year, and says Mango would have been entitled to reclaim this cost from Carlyle anyway.

Salaries

In the meantime, the staff of SAA’s subsidiaries are bearing the brunt of the precarious financial situations of these companies.

SAA has been in business rescue since December 2019, but this did not include the subsidiaries.

The SAA business rescue practitioners are therefore not legally mandated to spend any of the post-commencement finance to assist the subsidiaries.

The staff of a third subsidiary, Air Chefs, have not been paid since the hard lockdown, while SAAT staff have only received between 25% and 50% of their salaries every month for the last year.

Read:

In May last year Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan told parliament that Mango would cut staff salaries by 50%.

In March SAAT management promised to pay full salaries for the first time, but eventually only paid a portion early in April and have paid nothing since.

In a message sent on April 7, staff were encouraged to apply for shortened work hours and take paid or unpaid leave. That would “enable the likelihood of SAAT paying 100% of the worked half-time”, staff were told. The situation will be reassessed at the end of June.

Domino effect …

The National Union of Metalworkers (Numsa) has been vocal about the problems within the SAA group and is considering litigation.

Solidarity said staff at SAAT are “very close” to withholding their labour.

That could result in an even deeper crisis for the airlines that depend on SAAT for technical services – including Mango, SAA, Comair’s Kulula and British Airways flights, as well as several international airlines.

Several aviation experts confirmed that SAAT must inspect their clients’ aircraft before flights and certify that they are airworthy. If SAAT staff are unavailable, it could take time to make alternative arrangements and this could disrupt flight schedules.

Local airlines FlySafair, Airlink and CemAir do their own repairs and maintenance and are therefore not dependent on SAAT.

Comair has been trying to wean itself off SAAT for some time by entering a partnership with Lufthansa Technik to establish a local facility, but that was dependent on Comair’s purchase of several Boeing 737 Max 8 aircraft.

The Max was however grounded globally after two devastating air crashes elsewhere and Comair, which has since gone into business rescue, is cancelling the order. Comair is therefore reviewing its partnership with Lufthansa Technik.

Minister’s focus not on strategic asset

Transport economist Joachim Vermooten questions Gordhan’s focus on SAA, which provides a service that many other airlines also do, while seemingly ignoring SAAT, which has a strategic role to play in South Africa and the region.

Auditor-General Tsakani Maluleke reported that SAA has not submitted financial statements for 2019/20. There is substantial uncertainty about its ability to continue operating as a going concern with it being in business rescue.

The subsidiaries also failed to submit financial statements due to SAA’s business rescue and the “interdependencies of the subsidiaries within the group”.

Mango funds

Mango’s financial statements for the previous year are also still outstanding, she stated.

In the last available SAA statements, for 2016/17, the group reported that SAA held R357 million of surpluses on behalf of Mango in an interest-bearing account.

Mango confirmed that it got the money back from SAA, but when the SAA business rescue practitioners (BRPs) Les Matuson and Siviwe Dongwana took control in December 2019, there was nothing left of it and Mango owed SAA R300 million, which is still outstanding.

The BRPs earlier indicated that they planned to substantially conclude the SAA business rescue by the end of March. That could have enabled funds transfer from SAA to its subsidiaries, but the BRPs missed the deadline with no further indication of a new schedule.

Read:

COMMENTS   19

Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in to comment.

SIGN IN SIGN UP

Will someone just flush the toilet please !!!

I did, but we have a floater that won’t go down.

Mine look like Zuma and the general ANC ilk

Mango’s skeletons are crawling out of the cupboard one by one now; like SAA its holding company, NO audited financials for many years, lies about so-called profitability when in fact SAA was secretly pouring tax-payers money into it to fool the public, and so on.
The AG had quite a bit to say about Mango in her latest report…
Boycott Mango and SAA – chances are a booked seat on Mango won’t take off, and money won’t be refunded!

Everything broke, due to ANC corruption and mismanagement.

It has been testing times for for all suppliers to fraught SOE’s in SA – the ANC just cannot run a spaza shop and they want to run the SOE’s but end up running them ALL into the ground.

Where is the CAA in all this? Surely the technical capability of SAAT to maintain aircraft is severely compromised in this situation? Wonder what their incident reports look like lately? Would you feel confident in getting on aircraft that had gone through SAAT at the moment? Shut it, privatise or whatever, just resolve the issues….stop dragging things on hoping that if everyone resigns/works for no or little pay that you can re-structure without liabilities. Pathetic and dangerous tactics.

It is like the traffic cop overlooks unroadworthy taxis and unlicenced taxi drivers. The ANC boss owns the taxi, pays backhanders to his mates in the council or wherever, and to Lootfreely House so they are untouchable. Argue with the ANC and you are gone, law or no law; same with the SAA pilots.

Same with SAA; the CAA will grant them exemptions and overlook transgressions and, like the taxis, SAA will keep costing money, scare people then probably start killing people. Welcome to Azania.

By far the biggest issue at SAA and affiliates like the technicians and Mango is SAFETY concerns! That’s since the vaccine flight to Brussels with under-trained pilots and the attempted cover-up and late-reporting of a serious safety incident shortly after take-off by the SAA Airbus.

Hopefully SAA technical can be sold to a private buyer. It provides useful services as long as it can choose its customers.

Aircraft technicians are some of the most ingenious and capable people I know. And now they are working for 25% of their salaries – and I won’t be surprised if they feel useless and hopeless as a result. Highly skilled and capable people feeling useless – what a disservice to them.

Welcome to the rainbow nation of disservice,

a product of “clever progressives”, since emigrated and living in other well run countries..

By the end of the month all of their licensed AME’s will be gone. Let’s see if the CAA will turn another blind eye like they did with the Brussels fiasco

For sure! What really angers tax payers and the public is the “Air Chefs” with their crazy demans at the time; since when do coffee and snack staff get a 13th cheque year after year, pensions, etc? In real life they work on a smallish basic with tips from customers. But not so at Gordhan’s SAA.
Look after scarse skills at SAAT – but clearly this too is a “&$#+

Decolonization going well. Another good story to tell.

Decolonialised education a shining beacon of utter hopelessness,!!
Safair is the only airline in RSA with a clue of how to run an airline .I will rather drive than fly any of the others .

Comair and Safair are the best locals to fly with

Just let SAA tank already!

The pilots and techs will be scooped up by other airlines who can fill the demand (short term pain for long term gain).
I wish someone could coordinate this, and perhaps even have a find to help the staff whilst the withhold labour from SAA.

Pilots now heading to labour court – good! DPE misrepresents situation and as expected, plays the race card when cornered. What’s new in government!

End of comments.

LATEST CURRENCIES  

USD / ZAR
GBP / ZAR
EUR / ZAR

Podcasts

INSIDER SUBSCRIPTIONS APP VIDEOS RADIO / LISTEN LIVE SHOP OFFERS WEBINARS NEWSLETTERS TRENDING PORTFOLIO TOOL CPD HUB

Follow us:

Search Articles: Advanced Search
Click a Company: