Proudly sponsored by

Should I cash in my preservation fund to buy a rental property to supplement my income?

Advantages and disadvantages of taking this approach.

I have R700 000 sitting in a preservation fund from when I resigned from my company. I am considering withdrawing and investing the money in a rental property to supplement my income. What would the advantages/disadvantages of doing this be?

  Profile         Mail

First of all, I must congratulate you for keeping the R700 000 in your preservation fund up to now.

In order to provide you with a meaningful answer, some more details would be required. I will however answer your question in a generic manner which hopefully will provide you with the information you are seeking.

There are two decisions you need to make, each with its own challenges. Firstly, is it wise to withdraw from your preservation fund, and secondly, do you understand all the ins and outs of the residential property rental environment?

The following factors must be taken into consideration during your decision-making process:

  • How many years do you have before reaching retirement age? (I assume you are not yet retired, hence the consideration to withdraw from the preservation fund and not retire from it).
  • Do you currently own a primary residence? If your answer is yes, do you have a bond registered over the property?
  • Do you have debt? (Credit card, overdraft, clothing accounts, motor vehicle and so on.)
  • Are you planning to buy the rental property cash or are you going to bond it?
  • If you intend to bond the rental property (which you should do), will you be able to afford the bond without a tenant if the interest rate is 5% higher than today?
  • Have you previously withdrawn funds from your preservation fund? Regulations allow only one withdrawal from a preservation fund once the funds have been preserved.
  • Are you married, and in whose name will the property be registered?

To prevent duplication of a previous article I wrote please read Investing in property: The good, bad and the ugly, which was recently published on Moneyweb.

In the article, I elaborate on the benefit of gearing rental property rather than buying it cash and many of the pros and cons of property ownership.

Rental property is not a bad idea as long as you are aware of the pitfalls and complications that you will experience as a rental property owner.

Withdrawing from your preservation fund will attract tax. Only R25 000 will be tax-free, with the balance being taxed at 18% on the next R635 000 and 27% on the balance up to R990 000.

Remember that preservation funds are tax-exempt, meaning that all growth and interest earned within the fund is tax-free. If you like property, you can up weight your property exposure to 25% of the portfolio value within your preservation fund. If you do decide to follow this route, please make sure you understand listed property before you make such an aggressive move. You can also take up to 30% offshore exposure in your preservation fund.

Preservation funds fall outside your estate, which means no estate duty will be paid on the proceeds in the event of your death. Preservation funds are also protected from creditors.

If it was my money, I would stick with the preservation fund but would make sure the investment portfolio is optimised.

If your main motivator for investing in a rental property is to supplement your income (cash flow), then first start by reducing debt – assuming you have debt.

It makes no sense to use cash to buy a rental property if you have a bond on your primary residence. Rather settle the bond should you have one. Rental property must be geared when you initially buy it in order for it to make sense. Refer to my previous article for an explanation.

The same applies to ‘bad debt’ such as credit cards, overdrafts and clothing accounts. These forms of debt generally attract high levels of interest. Before buying a property or investing in general, allocate a healthy portion of your free reserves to settling bad debt.

Reducing debt is the easiest way to improve your cash flow …

Good debt such as a bond on a rental property is fine, but as I mentioned previously, make sure you can afford the bond when (not if) interest rates increase and when (not in case) you do not have a tenant.

Good luck with your decision. Fortunately, your decision is a win-win situation, but you need to optimise the structure of your transaction to make sure you obtain the best result now and in the future.

Was this answer by Marius helpful?


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


Just use the Government RSA Retail bond…on a 5yr fixed with the 9.5% rate you will get R5500 per month clean from R700,000
If the rates ever increase you can literally apply with your same application and obtain a higher interest rate with no penalty

No frills, no complications… and you retain your lump sum which you get after the 5 years (of course there will be inflationary depreciation)

This is the best , easiest and safest option.
It can all be done online… Their FICA restrictions are not as hectic as the banks

Buy to Let = Search @Financeghost on Twitter: Read his posts on the subject. Passive income, it is not.
Owning property for income is a business, it has Risk/Reward!
The JSE has many property maintenance-free options. Please do some serious homework before you commit.
I have both JSE listed property REIT’s in my Portfolio and I own property for let. REIT’s are giving me an income with no fuss!
My properties need painting and new facilities (More pain than gain)

Thank you for an excellent, unbiased, and informative comment. The bank will lend us money to buy a physical property, but they won’t finance the purchase of a listed property. This is the only advantage of a physical property compared to an investment in listed property. Financial gearing also leverages the risk to the same extent.

After all is said and done, any investment in local property is a vote of confidence in the ANC.

That’s exactly what I did. I used a lump sum and a bond to get an additional property. It took me 8 months to find the right property in the right area. Schools/municipal/City/lifestyle etc. BUT, the most important lesson for me was property management (post-purchase). The property agent and property management have made this all easy and possible for me to be an investor. Legal and Maintenance of the property are all their problem – But they take a fee. Worth every cent!

I cannot think of a worse investment than residential SA property to rent out. If people only knew and understand how difficult it is to evict a tennant that is not paying, no-one would invest in buy-let. The law is completely in favour of the tennant and as a landlord you will spend endless legal fees to evict someone after many months, even years.

I cannot emphasise too much how risky an investment like this is. Good luck to those doing this!

End of comments.



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Moneyweb newsletters

Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: