Proudly sponsored by

Should I sell my RMH shares or hold on to them?

If you sell your stock, you will realise the 46% loss.

Just after RMB Holdings unbundled from its respective FirstRand shares, I decided to invest in it at a weighting of about 10% of my portfolio. I was hasty and uninformed and reacted to a fallen share price. I have subsequently learnt more about shares and investing, leaving me with the understanding that it was a terrible investment.

Since then my RMH shares have slowly but surely declined 46%, leaving me with a terrible loss. I am willing to cut my losses and sell, allowing me to invest the residual capital into a more profitable company. However, I am unsure whether this is the correct decision to make. Could you please advise me on this decision? 

The question in summary: should I sell my declined RMH shares or should I hold on and wait?

  Profile      Follow      Mail

The math on the stock is: If you sell your stock, you will realise the loss of 46%. If you hold the stock, the stock will need to appreciate by around 80% to break even. Financials as a sector has seen a rebound over the last month or so, and so I would track the financial sector to see when there seems to be a technical peak.

I’m unfortunately not going to answer the question directly about RMH shares, nor comment whether or not it was a terrible investment. Harry Truman once said “Give me a one-handed economist. All my economists say, ‘on one hand…’, then ‘but on the other…” and this, unfortunately, is where the answer would be on this stock.

However, I will address the investing part, and how to select an investment stock and build a portfolio.

Investing in the stock market is not for the faint of heart: there are many risks involved in purchasing direct shares of a company. If your whole stock portfolio has comprised one stock, or multiple stocks that follow correlated returns, or you have built up a portfolio of stocks that are overweight in one specific sector, a change in economic policy, a surge or drop in oil prices or even a random pandemic can either give massive returns or devastating losses.

Investment portfolios are made up of the following asset allocations: cash, bonds, property and equities (also known as stocks and shares). Generally, cash is the least ‘risky asset’, followed by bonds (which also have different ranks of risk), then property, with equities considered to be the highest risk asset class.

Depending on your risk profile, and your risk tolerance, you will be able to build a portfolio that tries to track your expectations of returns, and volatility.

The due diligence that should be done on purchasing the stock of a company should be to look at the following:

  • Review the financial statements of the company and read the ‘footnotes’ which are often longer than the other financial information.
  • Review the senior management, and the management’s own financial transactions with the stocks: are they buying in their personal capacity because the company is trading at a discount, or are they selling because they think that it’s trading at an all-time high, or is it another reason due to some sort of restructuring?
  • Read up on how to build discount cash flow models.
  • Understand price-earnings (PE) ratios, and if it’s trading at an extremely high PE, whether it could be due to super revenues in the future.
  • Understand what you are buying and if you agree with the company’s operating model, and if it will be sustainable in the long run.

There have been many investors who have not followed the above and have done well, but there are many that have lost more than they have made, and the markets have become a casino where the house has won.

If you have time to do your due diligence and analyse each stock you buy, and you are not betting your house, then individual stock trading is for you.

If the above does not apply, and your value of generating income outweighs the time of doing the research then I would recommend hiring a professional. Alternatively, you can take the stock tips from your mates around the braai (I would probably avoid that strategy personally).

There are investment funds that aim to achieve certain outcomes, by setting a benchmark and having the mandate to be either conservative, moderate, or aggressive; or that have a mandate to invest solely in property as an asset class for example. They can also follow a valuation, momentum, macro, contrarian, or smart beta investment styles.

My recommendation would be to build up a diversified investment portfolio, using various funds to achieve your investment goal, based on your investment mandate. However, many of these fund managers do also get it wrong. So understanding your risk profile, and tolerance, is important.

Was this answer by Trent helpful?


Sort by:
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Top voted

You must be signed in and an Insider Gold subscriber to comment.


The man asked a straight question. Give him a straight answer.
Something like – yes, sell.
Or – no, don’t sell.

And give reasons.

@Chris. You know he can’t in the public domain without understanding the persons risk appetite.

@Chris fair criticism- @muks is correct with the FAIS Act and other regulation, there is a fine line between giving advice and “not advice”, and then there’s suitability requirements by investor risk profiling that needs to be done, which takes into account the clients age, investment time horizon, liquidity, expected returns, risk appetite, etc for me to provide advice to a client on specific stock or fund. I provide advice to my clients individual needs, after understanding their full financial situation, then it would be a direct yes or no, with the reasons why based on their situation. Answering questions on this platform as best I can within the limitations of the information provided.

Ah Chris you know this. The reader was misled by the title of financial advisor.

I bet my lunch if the reader had asked which financial product to buy this advisor would have mentioned a few.

Dear reader I have a four letter word for you. DYOR. Get it?

Just read the quality of advice you got from this response.

No way will I tell a person to sell. That is a responsibility one must do on your own. What happens if you tell somebody to sell and the share price after he sold it shoots through the roof. You can sell by method i.e. that if the price of a share drops by 10% you sell.

Trent, surely you should start by alleviating this poor investors concerns over RMH specifically? A big reason why he may have seen such massive declines in his RMH stock is due to the unbundling of Firstrand. He may not have noticed that he received Firstrand stock from this process? Currently, the remaining investment holdings in RMH are property related Atterbury Property Holdings, Atterbury Europe, Divercity and Integer Properties. Personally, I don’t believe it is a good time be selling RMH stock as property sector has been in a bear market for the past five years, property stocks are still cheap and represent good value. Property shares will likely rebound as rollout of covid vaccines kick in.

In ALL matters, define exit strategy before commitment.

Don’t sell – you will only realize your loss – it will bounce back>

This talk about “if you sell, then you have cemented in your loss” is useless advice and completely misses the point of the investment dilemma.

The issue is NOT whether to worry about selling. Or not.

The issue is, do I keep my money on this donkey, or can I find another faster-moving horse that will show a much quicker growth than the current donkey?

It seems the latter is indeed possible.

Find yourself “a faster horse” that can deliver a better growth than RMB promises to deliver ASAP.

You’ve ALREADY taken the haircut. Don’t make your current situation even more of a loss by dillygdallying with indecision, and NOT changing to a better horse.

End of comments.



Subscribe to our mailing list

* indicates required
Moneyweb newsletters

Instrument Details  

You do not have any portfolios, please create one here.
You do not have an alert portfolio, please create one here.

Follow us:

Search Articles:
Click a Company: